Showing posts with label Jodie Whittaker. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jodie Whittaker. Show all posts

Monday, 8 December 2025

Wish World / The Reality War


Chapter the 343rd, features a world and society from wish.


Plot:
Just like a Doctor Who producer in an anniversary year, the Rani wants to bring back Omega. He can apparently help to restart the Time Lord race - the only known surviving Time lords (her two bi-generated selves plus the Doctor) having become sterile following a "genetic explosion". Omega is trapped in a dimension that can only be reached by trapping the Doctor on Earth and then destroying the fabric of reality on that planet, over and over until it wears thin, using the power of doubt. To facilitate this, she travels back to Bavaria in 1865 to collect a baby who is one of the pantheon, the god of wishes. She has freed Conrad Clark from prison (after the events of Lucky Day) and has him wishing an approximation of Earth society into existence, warping reality for humans, and repeatedly replaying the 23rd May 2025. [Just as an aside: the Rani once ridiculed the Master for his plotting of silly, labyrinthine schemes - what a hypocrite!] On this version of the world, the Doctor believes he is John Smith, with a wife called Belinda and a daughter called Poppy. Conrad can't imagine a whole world, so people's experiences are created from their warped memories; this includes Poppy, who looks like the baby of the same name from Space Babies. The world adheres to Conrad's old-fashioned and heteronormative values (women should be wives and mothers rather than have paid work, a man can't find another man beautiful, disabled people are kept out of sight, trans people don't exist). Conrad appears on every TV as a cross between a Cbeebies presenter and God, telling stories of Doctor Who and the Rani. Anyone with doubts about this reality is carted off by the police. There are also giant dinosaur skeletons called Bone Beasts roaming about (don't ask why).


Ruby Sunday knows that something is wrong with the world and doorsteps John Smith, but he doesn't remember her. Smith goes to work at a drastically changed UNIT HQ (UNIT is an insurance company in this reality) where everyone but Shirley and Rose has an office job (Susan Triad is the tea lady). Shirley lives in a urban camp with other disabled people, and Rose isn't around at all. On John Smith's TV, Rogue appears, breaking through Conrad's transmission, and explains something about the falseness of Smith's reality. The resultant doubt gets Smith and Belinda carted off to the Bone Palace, the Rani's lair. The Rani explains her plan, and the Doctor realises who he is. She locks him on a balcony as the collective doubt of the populace tears the world apart. The balcony crumbles and the Doctor is falling to his doom when a portal opens, and Anita pulls him through into the safety of the Time Hotel. The day resets again. Anita explains that she has been searching for the Doctor through time, and found him stuck in the Rani's trap. The day keeps repeating, ending with the destruction of the world, but each time reality is wearing thinner, and soon the Rani will be able to free Omega. Anita opens another Time Hotel door into UNIT HQ and keeps it open; this brings reality to everyone there, and they all realise their true identities. Rose appears. The Doctor has a plan to restore reality, but he's worried that it will mean Poppy, who might be his actual half-Time Lord daughter, will cease to exist. Susan Triad (very rapidly) builds a zero room, which Belinda and Poppy get in. The Rani gets the Bone Beasts to attack UNIT HQ and there's a big battle.


The Doctor confronts both the Ranis at the Bone Palace. They have located Omega and free him; he's become a giant ghoul; Omega eats one Rani, and the other one flees. Ruby uses a UNIT transmat to reach Conrad and the wish god baby. She makes a wish and ends Conrad's world. The Doctor fights off Omega with the vindicator, then rushes to find his TARDIS as the Bone Palace disappears. Everyone returns to UNIT HQ, and opens the zero room. Poppy's still in there with Bel. The Doctor leaves the wish god baby, his power removed by the Doctor wishing for no more wishes, with Carla and Cherry Sunday to look after. He and Belinda plan to travel with Poppy in the TARDIS, but they start to forget her as does everyone else except Ruby. Poppy vanishes. Ruby persuades the Doctor that Poppy should exist, and he knows there's only one way to get her back: to use his regeneration energy to adjust the timeline. He goes off alone in the TARDIS and sees his previous Jodie Whittaker incarnation, who gives him a pep talk then disappears. He forces a regeneration, but doesn't change yet - he floods the TARDIS with the energy streaming out of him, then finds himself in a garden (somehow). He finds Belinda and her daughter Poppy. In this timeline, Poppy is 100% human and is Belinda's child with an ex; she has been wanting to get back to Earth on the 24th May 2025 as Poppy needed looking after. The Doctor says goodbye, then materialises the TARDIS in space near to the star that used to be Joy Almondo, and his regeneration takes place: he changes into a body that looks exactly like Rose Tyler, "Oh hello!".


Context:
I watched both episodes back-to-back from the Blu-ray box set on an evening early in December 2025. I viewed it in this way to see how well, or how not so well, both parts cohered as one story, given the major reworking of the ending that I know about now, but didn't know to quite the same level of detail on first viewing (see the Reaction section below for more on that).

Milestone watch: I've been blogging new and classic Doctor Who stories in random order since 2015, and I'm now approaching the point where I catch up. This story completes a season (new series 15, as I call it) and another Doctor's era. Ncuti Gatwa makes it 14 Doctors whose televisual eras have been completed (Doctors 1-4, 6-15), and 40 out of the 41 seasons completed to date (classic seasons 1-18, 20-26, and new series 1-15). Of the 892 episodes of Doctor Who from An Unearthly Child up to The Reality War, four now remain. There is also at the time of writing a new 5-episode spin-off that has begun broadcasting.


First Time Round:
I first watched Wish World on the BBC iplayer around 10am on Saturday 24th May 2025 (the day which the episode revolves around); I was accompanied, as I was for most of the series, by middle child (boy of 16, 15 at the time). The two of us also watched the second and final part The Reality War together, but not on the TV. We occupied two seats in a full house of people watching the episode in the Duke of York's cinema in Brighton. As for the previous year's finale, there were cinema showings across the UK. I couldn't interest either of the other children, though the eldest - back from university - joined his brother and I for a meal in the next door pub The Joker before the screening, then afterwards went out with mates for the evening rather than watch Doctor Who on the big screen. Once we'd said goodbye to him, the two of us went to the cinema and settled in our seats just as the introduction by Varada Sethu was starting. The crowd, including the two of us, made all the right noises of enjoyment throughout. We gasped in amazement at the surprise appearances (Anita from the Time Hotel! Rose Noble!), and were shrieking in amazement by the time we heard Jodie Whittaker's first line of dialogue. I think most people had lost their voices to amazement by the time Ncuti regenerated into Billie Piper at the end. One audience member still mustered decent projection, though. At the very end, as the lights came up - he had held it in through the full credit sequence and the teaser for The War Between the Land and the Sea - he very loudly and in heartfelt fashion exclaimed "What the f**k?!" to everyone in the cinema, and we all chuckled with understanding at his shellshock.


Reaction:
I obviously have to give my reaction to the version of this story that ended up on screen, but before that I'll briefly cover the version that didn't. For Who's 62nd anniversary, Sunday November 23rd 2025, deleted scenes from Ncuti Gatwa's second season were released online for fan appreciation. Not all the deleted scenes, though. As fans instantly pointed out, the clips package had an omission as big as an elephant in the room. Many of those involved had leaked the nature of The Reality War's original ending, but the production team still seemed to want to pretend it didn't happen. The Doctor and his friends were to have finished up in a club dancing in celebration and happiness (an accidentally uploaded promo picture showed a moment from this scene), watched from afar by the Doctor's granddaughter Susan played by Carole Ann Ford, accompanied by Poppy. Both observers would have then slunk away, with Susan saying to Poppy 'Come on, Mum'! It would have been a wonderful moment. The puzzle remains as to what connective story tissue would have joined that final scene to the earlier narrative. It's hard to tell exactly what's been added later, but I think there may be a hint from paying attention to the presence or absence of Rose Noble. The character appears once reality is reintroduced to UNIT HQ, to be emblematic of people of whom Conrad's narrow worldview can't conceive. The character isn't given enough to do, just as she wasn't in the previous year's finale; but, she's there, alongside the rest of the UNIT gang, helping to rescue Poppy (who might cease to exist). This is the first time that Poppy needs to be rescued after the first threat of non-existence. The second time this happens (this egregious double story beat is no doubt a side-effect of the rewrite), everyone else from the gang is still present at UNIT HQ, but Yasmin Finney obviously wasn't free and Rose is absent.


So, everything up to Poppy's miraculous survival in Susan Triad's zero room was probably material from before the rewrite. Then, perhaps, everyone forgot about Poppy in a similar way to how they do in the final version, but without Ruby as the lone dissenting voice. Poppy wouldn't have vanished, and would instead have met up with Susan for the original ending. This would explain loose ends in the final version; the cameo appearances of Susan earlier in the season, for example, end up going nowhere and linking to nothing, as does the stand-out line from 2024's finale where the Doctor explains that he has a grandchild but no children (as Time Lords tend to do things out of chronological order). A neat little tie-up that we did end up getting is Ruby's awareness of parallel realities because of her experiences in 73 Yards. This is used to good effect in Wish World to explain her distrust of Conrad, then used again in The Reality War as an explanation for why she alone still remembers Poppy. Unfortunately, this creates what for me is the most unfortunate impact of the rewrite. In the - rather wonderful, horror-inflected - scene of Bel and the Doctor passing Poppy's coat between them as it gets smaller and smaller, Ruby sees what is happening, and knows what they've forgotten. Was this scene in the original version? Could have been, but I think probably not. The next sequence can't have been, though: the Doctor arrives at UNIT HQ and - with persuasion from Ruby - goes off to realign the universe to bring Poppy back, with a hint that it will cost his life. The surprise of Jodie Whittaker's cameo, and the scene where the Doctor returns to normality and finds that everything has changed, with Bel always having had a child to whom she has been trying to get back all this time, distract one on first watch from the the devastating truth that the Ncuti Doctor never says goodbye to Ruby.


Millie Gibson might appear instantly that the Christmas special starts in 2026, of course, but the damage is done. Ruby was Gatwa's first and most important companion. She sends him on the mission to save Poppy, but by the end of The Reality War hasn't seen him again, and knows nothing of whether he's been successful or not. His sole goodbye scene is with more recent companion Bel, who - unlike Ruby - was blissfully unaware that anything was wrong before. If he had had the choice, I don't think writer and showrunner Russell T Davies would have structured the story like this. Wish World / The Reality War as a whole is therefore compromised, and doomed always to be seen more as a set of scenes than a story. Luckily, most of its individual scenes are great - imagine if they weren't? - but there will always be the lingering impression whenever one watches it that they don't quite fit together. The story has forced upon it the job of completing a Doctor's era thematically, and instead summarises the last two years of Doctor Who more as a highlights package. Everyone significant returns for at least a brief moment. All the many UNIT regulars are there, as mentioned, including Susan Triad and Mel, who hadn't returned earlier in the season. They are given fun alter egos in Conrad's world as employees of the Unified National Insurance Team. It's great to see Rogue appear on John Smith's TV to alert him to the inconsistencies of his current reality, and to say "I love you"; Ruby's mum and grandmother get to adopt the wish god baby at the end, which is a perfect fit and harks back to Ncuti's very first full story The Church on Ruby Road; best of all for me was the unexpected return of Anita from the time hotel, one of my favourite characters of recent years. The Doctor regenerates in the presence of the Joy star (like Anita, returning from the last Christmas special). Even the Giggle is heard from the story in which Ncuti first made an appearance.


Another regular guest star returning who's featured throughout Ncuti's two seasons is Anita Dobson as Mrs. Flood, one of the Two Ranis (Dobson's exit line doing a gag about The Two Ronnies got a good, groanful reception in the cinema where I first watched the story, though I'm sure a lot of the audience were too young to have got the reference). She's very good value as we've come to expect, and has great screen chemistry and interplay with Archie Panjabi as the lead Rani. Every scene with Panjabi is lifted by her presence, the costume is great and it's great to see her zooming about the sky on her space jet-ski. It's also great to have a brief flashback to Kate O'Mara playing the character, and to have a Mel-Rani face-off . It seems a shame for Panjabi to be killed off, but maybe she could survive being eaten by Omega and return one day. The Omega creature is nicely realised, but it does seem odd to bring him back not looking or acting anything like the character previously did. At least the difference is explained in the script, and it is hard to think what other Gallifreyan MacGuffin could be the Rani's goal. Also unfortunate is Gatwa's stressing of a different syllable when pronouncing Omega's name compared to everyone else in the story (and everyone through Doctor Who's history); but, he's a Time Lord, so can say things however he wants. The larger-than-life villainy on display somewhat overshadows Conrad Clark, but the script makes a virtue of this. Conrad finds some measure of goodness and humanity within himself in wishing his world (as Ruby says, it could have been a lot worse) and he gets a happy ending. There's freaky visual interest provided by the Seekers and the Bone Beasts, as well as a nice action set piece involving the latter when they attack UNIT HQ.


Varada Sethu gets less interesting, and less effective, material here than Millie Gibson: the moment where she runs from her house into the woods of Conrad's world and screams in despair is great. If she has such doubts, though, then the various moments where she seems disproportionately aggressive at the idea of Poppy not being her daughter don't ring true. Sienna-Robyn Mavanga-Phipps as Poppy is astonishingly good, though, and Sethu works well with her. With any time-travel story where history is altered, there is always uncertainty about whether things have been put back as they always should have been at the end, or have changed. Which was the prime timeline? Did Bel always have a daughter, and the initial timeline was the one that was out of whack? Maybe it doesn't matter, but personally I'd like to know one way or the other. Talking of the end, I'll finish by looking at the denouement as it finally ended up, rather than the one in a parallel universe of potential story energy. The accumulation of returning elements already there before the story had to become a regeneration story look difficult to top, but Davies pulls out all the stops such that the last 20 minutes or so achieve an operatically unhinged energy. With everything else seeming to leak, the production team's keeping Jodie Whittaker's appearance secret was a major coup. Every moment and every line of the scene of her and Gatwa is wonderful. She was always a more awkward Doctor when dealing with emotions than Gatwa's take on the Time Lord, and this is addressed in the final exchange where Whittaker feels she should tall Yaz that she loves her, and Gatwa replies "You never do... but she knows". Just when one might think that the surprise level has peaked, Gatwa regenerates into Billie flippin' Piper. As the man in the cinema suggested (see First Time Round section above) the story ends with the consummate WTF moment.


Connectivity:
This is irritating; the connection between Wish World / The Reality War and Redacted could have been the slam dunk that both have surprise appearances by Jodie Whittaker as the Doctor towards the end. Unfortunately, that's only true of Redacted series 1, not series 2. Oh well. Instead, it will have to suffice that both stories feature displaced people living in a makeshift community ruled over by a cruel female villain (the Rani, Honour Bray).

Deeper Thoughts:
Ncuti in summary. In the first month or two of 2025, it didn't feel (at least to me) like the year would see the end of an era. 2024's Christmas special Joy to the World was fresh in my mind, Doctor Who was gearing up for the second season of a bright, young and relatively new Doctor, paired with an intriguing new companion. At that point or thereabouts (the producers of Doctor Who are being a bit cagey about the exact timing), Ncuti Gatwa had already finished filming on the series. As mentioned in the Reaction section above, it's common knowledge that the ending originally planned for The Reality War would have seen some loose ends left to be tied up about the Doctor, his granddaughter and daughter; but, at the end of it, the Doctor would be unregenerated and celebrating with his friends. The next season, which was already at least partially scripted, would have picked up from there. It didn't come to pass: either Disney+ delayed too long in making a decision on whether to coproduce that next season, or they had already made a decision but it wasn't communicated publicly, and the BBC needed time to decide what to do next with Doctor Who. It doesn't really matter why or how, the important thing is that it was too much of a delay for Ncuti Gatwa and, no doubt, for his agent. Put yourself in the agent's place: your client is a hot property, and he's getting offers for movies. As I said on the blog back in 2023 (see the Deeper Thoughts section of the Boom Town post for more details), Gatwa was probably "the most up-and-coming" of any actor on taking up the Doctor role, "young and exciting, and clearly has the potential to move on to greater things". A man in a hurry, in other words (even if he hadn't had an agent pushing him onwards).


Ncuti was clearly up for doing a third year (likely no more than that) if and only if he could go straight into making it after his second season. The delay scuppered that, and so the finale needed to be rewritten and reshot to divest him of the baggage of association with a high-profile role, letting him move on. I can forgive showrunner Russell T Davies's white lies stating that Gatwa's two-year stint was "always the plan": hell hath no fury like a mass of Doctor Who fans scorned, after all; it's not Gatwa's fault the plan changed, and nobody sensible wants him to be hounded by those fans forever more. The pronouncement had some traces of truth, anyway: the plan probably always was for Gatwa to film his regeneration in 2025, but he was almost certainly expected to film another season's worth of episodes first. In that Boom Town post's Deeper Thoughts section, I drew parallels with Gatwa's and David Tennant's profiles when they were cast as the Doctor. It's an intriguing counterfactual to consider what might have happened if Tennant in 2007 had faced a delay before his third season went into production: would his fan love for Doctor Who have made him hang around for an extended period associated with but not playing the role of the Doctor? It's nice to think that fandom would conquer all, but Tennant too was a young actor with bags of promise, and he too would likely have bowed to pressure from his agent. The November 2025 comments from The Rest is Entertainment podcast (amidst an otherwise even-handed reaction to the Disney+ decision) that Gatwa wasn't sufficiently ambassadorial - with the hint that this was because he wasn't sufficiently invested in the hugeness of the role - were therefore a bit unfair. Could anything Ncuti have done in promoting the show have got more people subscribing or watching on Disney+? I doubt it.


I think the situation probably arose simply because the first few Gatwa stories didn't land with a lot of the audience. I didn't mind any of his opening three stories (The Church on Ruby Road, Space Babies and The Devil's Chord), but I nonetheless look back and think they are probably the weakest three stories of any that he did. Even when his first series hit its stride (with 73 Yards and Dot and Bubble, stories that were - for me at least - up there with some of the best that Doctor Who of any era has had to offer) Ncuti Gatwa was barely in it. With hindsight it's easy to suggest it was a bad move to cast someone who couldn't start straight away (Gatwa had commitments to Sex Education, the series that had first brought him to the public notice, that overlapped with the recording dates for those first Who stories made for his era, meaning they had to be 'Doctor lite'). I'm terribly conflicted on this: 73 Yards wouldn't work if the Doctor was in it throughout, and it's marvellous exactly how it is. Did the programme win that battle only to lose the war? People carp about the finale of that first year (I think both parts, The Legend of Ruby Sunday and Empire of Death, are cruelly underrated), but was its quality irrelevant? Had people already given up because the first part of the season featured stories that were either a bit naff, or didn't feature the Doctor, or both? We'll never know for sure. At the end of 2024, Joy to the World came along and was simply joyful (as mentioned above, the character of Anita from that story returning unexpectedly in The Reality War was a glorious high point for me, and I'm sure for others too). No matter how good any story was from then on, though, the series was a lame duck as far as the press was concerned.


If the first season was under-Doctored, the second was overshadowed. From months before its first episode aired, the tsunami of speculation about Doctor Who's future could only ever drown out anything positive about the 2025 run. By that time, those reshoots had been done to change the ending of the final episode, and some details of that had leaked. This was a shame as - despite some issues with script logic in a few of the stories, though nothing bad enough to impact their initial viewing - the series had corkers enough for everyone: if you liked action, there was The Well; if you liked quirkiness, there was Lux; if you liked camp splendour, there was The Interstellar Song Contest. As detailed above, the finale proved to be a bit lumpy and bumpy, with the story equivalent of crunching gear changes happening in a number of places towards the end of the second part. This was probably unavoidable given the behind-the-scenes reworking. I'm still fixated on just how extensive those reshoots were. Behind the scenes footage shows producer Vicki Delow paying tribute to Gatwa as he wrapped on the series. This takes place on the UNIT set, which is hosting a veritable gang show - not just the UNIT regulars who might have been around anyway then for production of The War Between the Land and the Sea, but also Steph De Whalley as Anita and Susan Twist as Susan Triad. That's a lot of people to pay, and they also got Jodie Whittaker in for a day too. Given time, maybe Andrew Pixley will get sufficient access to document the truth for posterity. Or maybe not (there are still details from Christopher Eccleston's turbulent time filming his single season of the show that are tantalisingly unclear over twenty years later). Anyway, I doubt they'd have faked Delow's tribute just for Doctor Who Unleashed. (Side note: Unleashed and its energetic presenter Steffan Powell are a highlight of this era; I hope both show and presenter return when the main show comes back in 2026).


Whatever else one thinks of the creative decisions of showrunner Russell T Davies, one has to concede that he made original choices during his second tenure regarding the use of returning elements from the show's history. If you truly had the Toymaker, Sutekh and the Rani on your returning foes bingo card before the Bad Wolf Studios era of Who began in November 2023, then I salute you. This desire to do something a bit different, though, leaves Gatwa as the only Doctor never to have stories fighting against any of the 'big three' forces of antagonism of the Whoniverse (the Daleks, the Cybermen, the Master) and only the second not to have faced off against the Daleks. David Tennant's 14th Doctor at least got the Children in Need short with a Dalek (and, you know, he'd already played the part and had three full-on Dalek stories first time round). For Paul McGann, though, Skaro's finest only featured as off-camera voices. He only did the one story, though. It would be a shame if this dented Gatwa's legitimacy in anyone's eyes. Ncuti himself covered this in a The One Show interview in July 2025, saying "I never got to fight a Dalek. A Dalek or a Cyberman. I mean, just the crux of Doctor Who", then adding a tease: "So, might do that! Might go fight a Dalek!". He won't, of course. Even if he was serious, his agent wouldn't let him, much as I'd love to sit down on Christmas Day 2026 to a surprise reappearance of Gatwa allying himself with Billie Piper to defeat the dastardly dustbins. What about a few years after that? I suspect that Gatwa is going to be as busy in that time as Matt Smith - who has never returned to Doctor Who despite seeming quite enthusiastic about the idea. So, even if enough time passes to pacify an agent, it seems improbable. Nothing's impossible though, and Gatwa's Doctor clearly has unfinished business with his granddaughter Susan: one day, he could come back - yes, one day...

In Summary:
What the f**k?!

Thursday, 26 June 2025

Doctor Who: Redacted (series 1)

Chapter the 331st, features the adventures of three people who podcast about the Doctor.


Plot:
Three friends, Cleo, Abby and Shawna, host a podcast about a mysterious blue box, and all the various conspiracies that surround it (diet pills that create alien fat babies, hospitals disappearing and ending up on the moon, statues of angels that move when you're not looking at them, etc.). Abby is the Mulder-style believer, who puts this all down to alien activity. Shawna is the cynic who would rather assume they are man-made conspiracies. Cleo is the joker, just there to bring the sass (but underneath is fiercely loyal and brave). Some of their fellow bloggers and podcasters are disappearing, and files are being corrupted. The trio interview some key figures in the history of the blue box like Rani Chandra, as well as [Redacted] and [Redacted]. After talking to the trio, though, these people go missing, and then Abby and Shawna forget they ever existed. Some people they talk to mention a woman associated with the box called the Doctor, but again after a while only Cleo is able to retain knowledge of a person of that name. The three are arrested by UNIT, interrogated and meet [Redacted] and [Redacted]. Abby decides to help UNIT, much to the other two's chagrin. They leave her and come into contact with [Redacted]. More and more people are disappearing and being replaced by ghosts, redacted from existence. UNIT manage to rig up a device to keep the ghosts at bay, and Abby is reunited with her two friends at the Powell Estate (where Cleo grew up). When Cleo is the only one left not to have been turned into a ghost, she sees the blue box arrive, and meets the Doctor. An intergalactic thought virus has been spreading throughout humankind. Cleo was immune as her psyche had blocked out a traumatic childhood memory of the Doctor after a previous encounter, which inoculated her. Together, she and the Doctor reverse the virus and return everyone to normal.


Context:
I recently had a conversation with a Doctor Who fan of my acquaintance (and he's no slouch, he's had books published and does a Doctor Who podcast, and that sort of thing) and he surprised me by telling me that there are still Doctor Who stories he has not seen. He's holding them back, saving them for a rainy day. I long ago used up all the classic stories, and have kept up to date with the new series stories. So, everything Who-related that I view for the blog is a rewatch, days, months or years after first having seen the story in question. After the conversation, I took the challenge of finding my own 'rainy day Who', and remembered this BBC Sounds spin-off series. I would watch the first of the two series, leaving the second for that future rainy day's listening. But would it pass muster with my usual rigorous canon-checker questionnaire? Does it star the Doctor? Yes. Was it released as an official Doctor Who or spin-off story (i.e. its not an unofficial fan-made proposition)? Yes. Is there a dramatic context to the story (i.e. it's not just a skit)? Yes. Was it released with the intention of being the main attraction for audience engagement (i.e. it's not just an extra on a DVD or Blu-ray)? Yes. Have I already covered it in passing with another connected story? No. With a full house of correct answers, I started my listening. The first series of Redacted is fairly long, 10 episodes of between 20 and 30 minutes duration, and took me a good couple of weeks of June 2025 to finish, listening to an episode every day or two.

Milestone watch: I've been blogging new and classic Doctor Who stories in random order since 2015, and I'm now closing in on the point where I finish everything and catch up with the current stories being broadcast serially. When not going off piste with spin-offs like Redacted, I have completed 11 Doctors' televisual eras, Doctors 1-4, 7-9 and 11-14, which entailed completing 37 out of the 41 seasons to date (at the time of writing): classic seasons 1-18, 20, 21, 23-26, and new series 1, 2, and 4-14.

First Time Round:
As mentioned above, this is my first time listening to Redacted. I do remember it being advertised online when it first became available, though. The first episode landed on the Sunday of the Easter weekend 2022, the same day that Legend of the Sea Devils was shown (and the same day I was writing it up frantically for the blog). I don't know why I didn't listen to it straight away, but probably I had too much in the 'to watch / listen' pile already at the time to commit to another long-running series. I always planned to get around to it sooner or later so I'm glad I've finally done so now.


Reaction:
As you'll see in the Deeper Thoughts section, I have not kept to my personal pledge to stay away from online news about Doctor Who. As such, I have further polluted my psyche with headlines like "Doctor Who Collapse: Woke Fans Join the Backlash", "Woke Doctor Who loses millions of viewers" and "Doctor Who’s ‘woke, boring rubbish’ storylines have caused staggering number of fans to turn off". I was momentarily amused by one site that had asked a surprisingly even-handed Mel Gibson to weigh in on the issue (reader, when I adjusted my glasses it turned out they were Millie Gibson's comments). Presumably the articles do represent some people's honestly held views. In all my many conversations IRL about Doctor Who, though, nobody's ever complained about it being too woke (however that's defined). It's usually positive (I was wearing my Van Gogh exploding TARDIS T-shirt on the tube the other day and a few young fans got talking to me about how much they enjoyed The Well); if there's any negatives it's usually about plot points or continuity. Nobody likes being preached at, of course, but I don't think Doctor Who does that too often. To pick a random example (but one that did create some annoyed articles at the time), 2025 season opener The Robot Revolution depicted a male character that was excessively controlling of his female partner. It gave that as a reason why the partner character stopped going out with him. Part of the story is some sci-fi shenanigans associated with this broken relationship being played out on a cosmic scale. The story never so much as hinted that all men are like the character, and didn't even paint him as a wholly bad person. Where is the room for anyone to feel targeted? If anything, it's too far the other way: he is presented in such a cartoonish way that nobody watching could possibly associate themselves with him, letting many off the hook.

The Burger King Kids' Club - selling burgers

It's not for me to dictate when people can take offence, of course. If people want to take offence about a negative representation, then they are of course free to do so. But what about taking offence at a positive representation? This gets a bit more tricky. As a BBC Sounds offering, Redacted was probably a little too niche to draw much attention. The Star Beast, though, the first 60th special in the year following Redacted series 1's broadcast, garnered 144 complaints from members of the public just because it, like Redacted, featured a trans character. That's not that many people, but it boggles my mind that even 144 people went to the effort to call in or use an online form to register their disgust that trans people exist and are being represented. What motivates anyone to do something like that? Stories are about people, and to be interesting they must be about a diverse range of people. Cleo Proctor, the protagonist of Redacted, is a great character, full stop - funny, dynamic and brave. That she's representative of a previously underrepresented group of people, some of whom would very likely be listening to the drama, is just a bonus. A cynic could see this as tokenistic. The band of heroes from UNIT and the TARDIS seen in Wish World and The Reality War thrillingly contains men and women, the young and the old, people of colour, cis and trans, queer and straight, and a wheelchair user. Someone tuning in that's not massively invested in the story might see this as the shallow box-ticking inclusivity of something like the Burger King Kids Club. But these characters don't exist to sell burgers, they exist to represent humanity versus the baddies. Besides, they're all great characters, as are the heroes of Redacted. Unlike the perhaps over-staffed UNIT of 2025, the three characters at the heart of the audio drama (who do form something of a cross section of LGBTQ+ women, one lesbian, one bisexual and one trans woman) all have a lot to do in the story.

The Doctor and friends - saving the world.

Head writer Juno Dawson and the other writers create a series that's a celebration of new Who. It was an obvious joke in the synopsis above to redact the names of some of the characters cameoing from Who's history, but I also did it for anyone who might be reading this and hasn't listened to Redacted yet: it would be much better to not know and be surprised by who shows up. Another cameo throughout the first nine episodes is Jodie Whittaker, occasionally leaving a voice message that gets scrubbed out by the burst of white noise that represents redaction. She is fully present for the final episode, with Cleo in the companion role. The revelation that Cleo has blocked out a traumatic memory from her childhood involving the death of a parent during a visitation of the David Tennant Doctor is exactly the same as a reveal in 2000s story Love & Monsters; it's so close a match that I'm chalking it up to homage rather than rip off. That the event in question is the "Red hatching" with Redacted building a backstory from a throwaway line from another 2000s Tennant story Blink backs that up. The use of our heroes' podcast recordings at the end as part of the plot resolution is a nice touch too. The only flaw - and it isn't that minor - is that 10 episodes is too long. After the first couple of episodes, the idea that people who have had any contact with the Doctor are gradually being erased is well understood by the audience, but it keeps happening for several more episodes, hammering the point home in a quite repetitive fashion. The beat where the trio are at their lowest ebb and split up acrimoniously seems to happen at least three times too. At the end, there's a step over the line into the overly preachy, comparing the impact of the redacting virus to online misinformation; mind you, a warning about steering clear of dodgy online content was one I could have done with, I suppose (see Deeper Thoughts for even more details).

Connectivity:
Both Redacted and Death of the Doctor feature a long section at the start where the Doctor is missing presumed dead, an appearance by Rani Chandra, and dubious behaviour by UNIT personnel.


Deeper Thoughts:
Out of the mouths of Beebies. Doctor Who has gone on hiatus three times before 2025. In 1985, it came back in 18 months; in 1989, it was back in seven years; in 1996, it took nine years. But it always came back. June 2025 is the first time since the return of 2005 that the programme is off the air without any commission in place for new episodes. This is similar to the situation of the latter two 21st century scenarios and so, just as it did in 1990 and 1997, speculation reigns. Unlike in the 1990s, though, this speculation is supercharged by website proliferation and social media. In the Deeper Thoughts section of the previous blog post I stated that this pause would be my opportunity to stop regularly googling 'Doctor Who' and looking at news articles. This turned out to be another prediction I made about Who that was wide of the mark. At the start of the year I speculated here that there would be a Christmas special aired in 2025, and that seems unlikely based on everything currently known. There is almost nothing that is currently known, though, so anything is possible. In this spirit, every news and entertainment site, both the big names and the smaller players, has indulged in flights of fancy based on almost nothing, and I haven't been able to resist reading them all. It is very like scouring fanzines in 1990 and messageboards in 1997, only more so. Doctor Who has no defined future, so it has any and every possible future. For example, recent rumours stated that the BBC were in discussions with Amazon, and that J. Michael Straczynski was involved (he apparently then posted in a reddit chat calling bullshit on all of this). Even the recent Doctor Who Magazine had no actual news about what was happening, and said as much (such were the restrictions of access to the finale, the magazine team were unaware of what happened at the end of The Reality War until it went out).


This didn't stop people reading meaning into the slightest mention or hint in the magazine's pages, though. Russell T Davies finished off his regular production notes column with a goodbye, his rationale being that a column about production of Doctor Who shouldn't be continuing when the production of Doctor Who was on hold. Many people immediately took this as a sign that he was no longer going to be running the show henceforth, and that there would be a long gap before the next series. It didn't really indicate either. The exact words he used were "Hopefully, we'll have news soon, and certainly, The War Between the Land and the Sea is about to break out, so there are great things ahead. Until then...". This suggests that the wait for that spin-off will not be too lengthy; indeed, elsewhere in the magazine it's confirmed it will be "broadcast on BBC One, BBC iPlayer and Disney+ later this year". Everybody else is doing it, so I too am going to speculate and risk seeing patterns in things that aren't there: the scheduling of TWBTLATS (using this initialism makes me wonder whether the show was ever titled The War Against the Sea at any point in development before someone realised that made a rude acronym) suggests to me that the Disney+ deal is dead, and they won't be contributing to any future episodes after the spin-off. If there were any chance that would happen, the spin-off would be held back to better bridge the gap between seasons. Showing it this year fits with getting the last Disney+ co-commissioned material out of the way to create a clean slate for a new production partner. It would also explain why no official announcement has been made yet: Disney will want to give the series they've paid for the best possible chance to bring in viewers / subscribers, so won't risk it being labelled a last hurrah (or lame duck) before it's been shown.


The one honest-to-goodness fact that has been reported about Doctor Who since the broadcast of The Reality War is a very positive sign, but certainly not one anyone predicted. Not even the most imaginative speculator nor the most informed 'insider' ever reported before the official announcement that Doctor Who was going to be made into an animated series for pre-schoolers on CBeebies. Whether or not you'll be planning to watch it should it get made (I am a completist, so will have to give it a viewing, even though my kids are far too old for it now), this has to be good news. Broadcasters don't tend to make pre-school spin-off versions of an intellectual property if they're not planning on continuing the main show. The Beeb, if not Disney, must have been happy enough with the last two years' performance. It doesn't mean that either the animation or further seasons of the main show will happen, of course - anyone watching the Who news closely from 1990 or 1997 saw many an article about projects in development that never got to a screen - but it indicates a strong motivation for the Whoniverse to endure. Some reporting on the press release and call for pitches mentioned that this series would have nothing to do with Disney+, though I haven't found an official source for that anywhere. If it's true, then it 100% would mean that the Disney+ deal was over: the House of Mouse's lawyers would almost certainly have drafted contracts such that the BBC couldn't make any spin-off of new Who without their go-ahead. If the BBC are proceeding with the Cbeebies show without Disney+ involvement, it suggests that any new Who of any kind will be made without Disney+ involvement. That would indicate that the popular general belief that the BBC is already shopping Who around other streamers is correct; we'll find out when we find out. I'm going to try to resist peeking at the internet until then...

In Summary:
It's another very enjoyable story that works as a celebration of all things Who, though it could do with being two episodes shorter. 

Tuesday, 1 April 2025

Ascension of the Cybermen / The Timeless Children

Chapter the 325th, in which the Doctor fought the lore, and the lore won.


Plot:
The far future; an intergalactic war rages between humans and Cybermen. Ko Sharmus is one of a resistance group that sends the Cyberium (wibbly energy glob that is the Cyber's battle AI and database) back in time, where it ends up at Villa Diodati. Semi-Cybernised zealot Ashad returns from the past having recovered the Cyberium. He and the remaining Cybermen hunt the few remaining humans. Ko Sharmus stations himself on a planet on which there's a portal to far off worlds, and helps humans to escape. Two time travellers, the Doctor and Ryan, accompanied by a surviving human, arrive at the planet. Ko Sharmus shows them the portal, but it's now continuously linked to the planet Gallifrey. The Master emerges and takes the Doctor back through. A Cyber ship arrives, and Cybermen attack. The three left on the planet defend themselves, and are saved by some Cybermen who turn out to be two more time travellers, Yaz and Graham, and two other surviving humans, disguised in Cyber suits. All seven walk through the barrier to Gallifrey to find the Doctor. The Cybermen also travel there in their ship. The Master shrinks Ashad with his Tissue Compression Eliminator, and takes the Cyberium. Sharmus and Co blow up the Cyber ship. The Master uses dead bodies of Time Lords to create a new group of Cybermen with the ability to regenerate: the Cyber-Masters. The Doctor finds the miniaturised Ashad; there is a superweapon still inside Ashad's Cyber suit that will destroy the Cyber-Masters. The Doctor takes it and confronts the Master, after having put everyone else in a TARDIS back to 21st century Earth. Ko Sharmus doesn't go with the others, and follows the Doctor. When she cannot bring herself to use the superweapon, he takes it from her and sacrifices himself. She just manages to escape before everything blows up. Suddenly, Judoon appear, arrest her and imprison her.


Parallel to this, there is the incongruous tale of Brendan, who lives in rural Ireland in the 20th century; he joins the police, miraculously survives a fall, retires many years later, and then has his memories wiped by some sort of electro-convulsion therapy machine. The Master had previously plugged the Doctor into the Matrix on Gallifrey and set off on some lengthy, lengthy exposition: the Doctor was a foundling taken in by Tecteun, a Gallifreyan; by chance, Tecteun discovered that her adopted child had the ability to regenerate, and extracted the genetic material controlling this, putting it into generations of Gallifreyans, who then became Time Lords. Brendan's story is part of the Doctor's history that has been wiped from her memory, adjusted in the matrix with a Ballykissangel filter.

Context:
There are very few stories left to blog now; I'm eking the last few out to allow for some to be shuffled in amongst the stories from Ncuti Gatwa's second run (still a couple of weeks away at the time of writing). The randomiser picked this story next, the most recently aired of those remaining, leaving only one other story to blog after this from the first phase of the new series from 2005 to 2022. I watched it from the iplayer over a couple of nights in March 2025. Slipback (a story from the mid-1980s) was still fresh in my mind, which was handy as I saw some parallels (more on this in the Reaction section below).


Milestone watch: I've been blogging new and classic Doctor Who stories in random order since 2015, and I'm now closing in on the point where I finish everything and catch up with the current stories being broadcast serially. This post marks the completion of another Doctor's televisual era; Jodie Whittaker's thirteenth Doctor joins the first, third, fourth, seventh, eighth, ninth, eleventh, twelfth and fourteenth Doctors, making ten completed to date. This also marks the completion of another season, the 36th out of the total of 40 seasons to date (at the time of writing): classic seasons 1-5, 7-18, 20, 21, 23-26, and new series 1, 2, and 4-14.

First Time Round:
Jodie Whittaker's second run, the 12th series after the relaunch of Doctor Who in 2005, aired each Sunday from the beginning of 2020. Its two part finale was broadcast on the 23rd February and the 1st March 2020, and I watched them both live accompanied by all the family. In between, on leap day, Saturday 29th February, I was at the BFI watching the animated version of The Faceless Ones (as blogged about in the Deeper Thoughts section of this blog post. Perhaps because the revelations hadn't yet come (all that was in the second part), I don't remember much discussion that day of the story currently being broadcast on the telly.


Reaction:
When he got the job as Doctor Who showrunner, I commented here that it wouldn't be too long before online wags highlighted Chris Chibnall's past appearance on a BBC TV programme, where he criticised mid-1980s Doctor Who, as an example of long-term karma. In this final blog post for a story from his tenure, I'm going to have to hark back to that. In 1986, Chibnall was one of a number of teenage fans on Open Air, a discussion programme about other BBC programmes; he couldn't know that many years later he'd be on the receiving end of similar criticism, so dished it out without compunction. I don't reference it to snipe, just to point out that - however critical he might have been of it - mid-1980s Who had clearly made a formative impression. I can't think of any other reason why so many years later, he wrote an Eric Saward script as the two-part finale of his second series in charge. Let's look at some of the evidence from Ascension of the Cybermen / The Timeless Children (which is a long-winded title that I'm tempted to abbreviate to just 'Ass'): a Doctor who doesn't drive the narrative, but is buffeted by overly bleak and violent action? Check. A mercenary character who is a more effective presence than the Doctor, in whom the writer seems much more interested than the nominal star of the show? Check. An unhealthy obsession with Time Lords and Cybermen? Check. It's like we've been pulled through a portal to another time and place. Just like Saward giving all the best lines in Revelation of the Daleks to his own character Orcini, so Chibnall allows Ko Sharmus to do all the fun stuff. Even minor points are similar: when Cybermen attack near the start, the fam get split up because they can't make it back to the TARDIS. Parking far away from the main action is something done in many a Saward story, including Revelation; at least Chibnall didn't have the Doctor spend the whole first episode walking to where all the other characters were.


There's a scene early on where the Doctor arrives with the fam with lots of gadgets to help the humans defend themselves against the Cybermen. All the devices are set up, named, discussed, and it sounds jolly impressive; then, they're blown up in an instant. The intention is clearly to up the ante by making the situation seem bleak, but that only works if the protagonist overcomes the bigger obstacles later; unfortunately, Jodie Whittaker's Doctor doesn't do this, as she's whisked off by the Master to her own subplot before she can do anything more in the Cyberman plot. Ko Sharmus, though, gets a very similar scene in the second episode but all his hardware is effective. It's not a one-off, either: the Doctor boasts about her ability to hotwire spaceships, but then some rando human can do it better than her. I found myself inwardly screaming 'It's her show, give her a win!' the longer things went on. There's nothing much that the Doctor gets to do other than receive information (this is harder to see on first watch as the surprise revelations about the Doctor's hitherto unknown past make it seem significant, but it's still exposition not plot). The only actual act that the Doctor does that's effective is using the power of her memories to break out of the Master's prison (a nice scene with lots of archive clips). The ending, though, has Ko Sharmus sacrificing himself to save the day, and the Doctor letting him do so with not much more than a shrug. This sort of scene is not unique to Doctor Who; the Doctor needs to survive to the next episode, so often someone else has to do the dirty work. The Doctor usually (and heroically) fights against this: the problem here is that the script and direction don't put her under sufficient pressure to make a decision, or have it made for her: Ko Sharmus needs to knock her out or lock her out of the room, or something along those lines.


The Doctor not being an active protagonist is far from the only problem; the surviving humans - only seven of them (who at first are presented as the only humans left, which later turns out not to be the case, an unnecessary extra confusion) - are a dull and featureless lot who don't speak like anyone you might have met. The script is also a bit contradictory about them: dialogue suggests that they are still very linked to their old lives ("We've got a childminder, a driver, a builder") but they are still able to act like expert soldiers, spies or saboteurs when the need arises. Additionally, a character who's presented as an older teenager confirms that he's been fighting Cybermen since he was four years old. Given the destruction this war is shown to have wreaked, is it feasible that people would still be as connected with their old lives after more than a decade, or indeed that there would be any civilisation left at all? Ashad's a dull villain with a tendency towards portentous speechifying; with the Doctor sidelined and the too many companions not having enough between them to do, this leaves only the Master. It's a great performance by Sacha Dhawan despite his character's motivation being hard to understand. Ian McElhinney as Ko Sharmus is solid too. There are some great visuals, but they often seem sterile (the beginning sequence with a cyber head floating towards the screen) or not aligned with the central premise (how is there still a big spaceship full of lots of dormant Cybermen, if they've been all but defeated?).


The most successful moments are those set in Ireland. The disconcertingly out of context interruptions depicting the life of the mysterious Brendan intrigue the audience precisely because they are disconcerting and out of context. It's almost a shame when they are explained as visions the Master has beamed into the Doctor's head (particularly as there's none of the traditional TV grammar that would normally be applied if a character was having visions - sometimes the Brendan cutaways happen when the Doctor isn't even on screen - so it feels like a cheat). The most controversial aspect of this story, the revelation of the Doctor's Timeless Child backstory, also works well. Many people dislike such a massive realignment of Doctor Who mythology, but it's clever and engaging, and is something that can be built on in future stories (as it was in Chibnall's Flux or in Russell T Davies' early Ncuti stories) without overwhelming the show. It has to be seen as something of a triumph in a nearly 60-year old show, to find a new take on the main character that was surprising but nonetheless broadly consistent with what had gone before. More analysis of this aspect of this story can be found in the Deeper Thoughts section of a blog post from close to the original transmission. It's just a shame that the delivery mechanism of these revelations is a fairly flat Cyberman versus humans story. 

Connectivity:
Both Slipback and Ascension of the Cybermen / The Timeless Children see the Doctor on a spaceship, and both stories feature aggressive law enforcement officers. In both stories, the Doctor is passive, not driving the story forward much or at all, with another Time Lord appearing partway through to explain things to them. The resolution sees a character other than the Doctor blow themselves up to save the day.
 

Deeper Thoughts:
Hand in hand through our... Arc life! Series and serials: Doctor Who fans who obsess over the details of its production and history (so, pretty much all of us) hear these terms all the time, but maybe don't think about them too much. When Doctor Who was first developed in 1963, there was a big difference between series (ongoing weekly adventures of a set of characters, plus new guest cast, that were one and done every week) and serials (bounded stories with mostly the same characters told over multiple weeks, with each episode forming only a part of an overall narrative that comes to a definite conclusion in the final episode). If there are antecedents, I'm not aware of them, so I think Doctor Who was the first, the mold-breaker, to be shaped as a series of serials. The challenges that the Doctor faces are not completed in a single episode, they take four or six or seven weeks, and the guest characters - and writer and director - stay more or less the same in that time; but then, once that challenge is resolved and a story comes to a firm conclusion, the fun doesn't end and there's a new story, new guest cast and different people involved behind the camera, following over multiple weeks. It's a very unusual approach; the televisual orthodoxy - particularly of that time in the 20th century - would dictate that if one is going to sacrifice the appeal of anyone being able to drop in at any particular point to engage with a clean slate, then it should only be for a short run; if one misses the first episode of a serial, then one is free to make a decision to watch something else for a few weeks, and then when another serial comes along it will be completely new with no baggage. With Doctor Who, there would be an unknown number of weeks before the next jumping-on point, and there would be at least some continuity between the serials.


This is probably why not many shows since have adopted the same format, and those that did - Sapphire and Steel, Timeslip, The Tomorrow People - were fantasy shows consciously modelling themselves on Doctor Who to a lesser or greater extent. What's curious, though, is that it worked: Doctor Who was a hit from that first series onwards, and in its 20th century run nobody considered changing the format. In the 1960s, production teams leant into it even more: there would be cliffhangers in between the serials too, making it one long adventure - singular - in space and time. One thing that probably helped it work is that the arcing narrative (that baggage that I mentioned earlier) was kept to a minimum: the Doctor was trying to get the two schoolteachers Ian and Barbara back home. That was it. Once those characters left, there was no arc plot at all, just a shared set of characters between the serials, and usually a cliffhanger to lead in to the next one. When Doctor Who was made in colour for the first time in the 1970s, the show was on for fewer weeks of the year, and those lead-in cliffhangers disappeared. For the rest of Jon Pertwee's years, the serials were not directly interlinked. A bit of arc plot came back in at this stage: mainly based on character dynamics (Jo Grant's growth as a person, Mike Yates's allying with the bad guys and the aftermath of that). This was the first time in Who's history when the final story of a run became a season finale, tying up some of those characters' plots, but it was still fairly loose. When Tom Baker took over, the new producer and script editor who came in with him got rid of even that. The last story of any particular run was usually the six-parter of that year, but the stories could have been shuffled into any order, and it wouldn't have made any difference.


A couple of times in the 1970s and 80s, the series experimented with linking all the stories under an umbrella theme - a quest to find the six pieces of the key to time, the Doctor on trial; but the last stories of those runs were the only other season finales of 20th century Who. It was probably a good decision; a year after the key to time season, a strike meant that the final story of the run, Shada, was not completed. With the potential disruption of industrial action always present (it killed off a story again in 1983), it was wise not to saddle any one serial with tying up a long-running narrative, just in case it never made it to screens. As the classic series of Doctor Who came to an end in the late 1980s, a pilot for a TV series being made in America was going to change the nature of things. David Lynch's Twin Peaks was influential in setting up a new standard: the detectives would not solve the murder at the show's heart in one week, the same investigation would continue the following week, and thereafter. Lynch, in his art school terrorist way, never wanted the case to get solved ever, but the network (and to a large extent the viewers too) disagreed. Since that experiment, the default has been established that one has to have a significant pay-off -  even if it isn't revealing everything - at the end of every season. It's more unusual for TV detectives to get a new case every week now than it is for them to get a new one every year. Series and serials have essentially become the same. Fantasy series have a bit more variety: the X-Files (probably the first major SF show to be influenced by Twin Peaks) was still in the story of the week mode, but with significant season or multi-season arcs. At the other end of the scale, Lost (whose creators have cited Twin Peaks as a significant influence) had minimal pay-offs from one year to the next, and frustrated many viewers.


When Doctor Who returned (an event celebrating its 20 year anniversary as I write this) it followed the X-files approach via Buffy. It was mostly single stories (though there were 2-parters in the mix too, as Doctor Who was felt to require cliffhangers) but with season-long arc plots, based both on developing character dynamics and also fantasy elements (usually a build up to the Big Bad confrontation in the season finale). Sometimes, showrunners planned their arcs over multiple years: Chris Chibnall sneaks in a reference to the Timeless Child within Jodie Whittaker's second story, long before it would be fully explained. Even to this day, though, there are still some echoes of Doctor Who's 20th century approaches too. The newly announced (at time of writing) episode titles, and writer and director credits, for Ncuti Gatwa's second season seem to confirm that its shape will be the same as the season in 2024: most stories the same length, but with one longer story at the end, just like Tom Baker used to do it. Pre-publicity has also suggested that the Doctor's aim throughout the run will be to get his new companion back home, just like he was trying to do with Ian and Barbara more than six decades earlier. Plus ça change...

In Summary:
The game changing exposition is actually quite interesting, and a neat idea, but it's surrounded by a bunch of ass -cension of the Cybermen.

Thursday, 2 May 2024

The Power of the Doctor

Chapter the 298th, where it's getting, it's getting, it's getting kind of hectic.


Plot:
All this written down in order is going to seem like the fitful dream of a kid who's gone to bed after eating too much sugar, but here goes anyway: The Doctor, Yaz and Dan battle against Cyber-Masters (regenerating Cybermen made from dead Timelords, with the collars and everything) on a floating train in space. The Cybermen kidnap the train's cargo - a wibbly energy creature disguised as a child. With this, the Master - allied with the Cybermen and the Daleks, and posing as Rasputin in the court of Tsar Nicholas II in 1916 - sets up a planet-sized Cyber conversion machine in orbit around Earth. Dan leaves to go back to his ordinary life, finding the Doctor's adventures a bit too dangerous after he nearly got killed on the space train. The Doctor's old friends Tegan and Ace have been recruited into UNIT by Kate Lethbridge-Stewart, and investigate some missing seismologists and missing paintings respectively. Tegan receives a package supposedly from the Doctor containing what looks like a toy Cyberman, labelled as a Russian doll. The TARDIS tracks the Cyber-Masters to the Cyber-planet in 1916, and finds the Master's TARDIS disguised as a police box. Kate calls in the Doctor; the Doctor and Yaz arrive at UNIT HQ and meet Tegan and Ace. The Doctor seems socially awkward meeting them, and somehow gives them both a static electric shock (which also happens later with Yaz). All the missing paintings have been altered to feature the Master as Rasputin, and the Master has sent a message inviting them to a location to attend his "keynote address" on seismology. When our heroes arrive, they find the missing seismologists all dead, shrunk by the Master's tissue compression eliminator.


Taken into custody and imprisoned in the UNIT building, the Master taunts Kate, Tegan and Ace. Following coordinates sent by a rogue Dalek, the Doctor takes the TARDIS to the inside of a Bolivian volcano. The Daleks capture her. In UNIT HQ, the Russian Doll Cyberman - which turns out to have been sent to Tegan by the Master - grows to full size and splits open, then troops of Cybermen emerge led by Ashad (a clone copy made by the Master before he killed the original). Kate is taken to be Cyber-converted, Tegan stays in the building to help Kate, and Ace escapes by parachuting from the roof. Vinder, on a mission to rescue the wibbly energy creature (remember that, from the beginning?) crashes onto the Cyber-planet. Yaz tracks the Doctor down in the TARDIS; she's been taken to Russia in 1916. After doing some disco dancing, the Master uses a process called forced regeneration to make the Doctor regenerate into a copy of him. Yaz arrives, and the Doctor-Master coerces her into joining him in the TARDIS. He goes off causing mischief, trying to ruin the Doctor's reputation. The Doctor (in her Jodie Whittaker persona) appears in a realm of consciousness and meets manifestations of old versions of herself - the Guardians of the Edge - who tell her there's a way she can reverse what the Master's done. Yaz manages to escape in the TARDIS, stranding the Doctor-Master on an asteroid somewhere in space. A holographic AI version of her Doctor appears before Yaz, implanted by the real Doctor earlier who passed it off as static electricity. With that guidance, Yaz is able to pick up Vinder and Ace. The latter is dropped off at the volcano to stop the Daleks, the former hides in the TARDIS as Yaz goes back to collect the Doctor-Master.


Holo-AI Doctors (looking like the Peter Davison and Sylvester McCoy versions) appear to Tegan and Ace too. Ace meets Graham, who's also investigating the volcano. The Daleks set the volcanoes all over the world to erupt. With help from Vinder and the holo-AI Doctor, now looking like the Fugitive Doctor that was hiding out in Gloucester, Yaz manages to reverse the forced regeneration process. Tegan rescues Kate and they both escape UNIT HQ, just before it is blown up (Tegan having sabotaged the Cybermen's equipment with help from her holo-AI Doctor). Ace and Graham set Nitro-9 charges in the volcano. The TARDIS comes and picks everyone up, and the Daleks are all blown up. With the extended fam's help, the Doctor stops the eruptions by Cyber-converting the lava, turning it into steel. She sends Vinder back home, and then asks the wibbly energy creature (it's still hanging around) to destroy the Cyber-planet. The dying Master is still on the planet, and uses the creature's power to zap the Doctor, fatally wounding her. Yaz returns everyone else home, and has one last moment with the Doctor, the two of them sitting on the TARDIS roof eating ice cream while it floats in orbit around planet Earth. The Doctor tells Yaz she has to do the next bit alone. After being dropped off, Yaz immediately bumps into Graham and Dan - they are on their way to a support group that Graham has set up for friends of the Doctor on Earth. The meeting includes Kate, Tegan and Ace as well as some other old friends Ian, Mel and Jo. The Doctor regenerates atop Durdle Door, regaining a familiar set of teeth...


Context:
In the 1980s, episodes that were longer than Doctor Who's usual 25 minute duration (The Five Doctors feature 20th anniversary length special, for example) were sometimes chopped up for repeat or overseas showings, with new credit sequences shoved in to make them fit the majority pattern. I'd had a passing thought when I was writing the Deeper Thoughts section of The Krotons blog post in 2023 about whether any fan had created such edits of new series shows. Remembering this, I decided to experiment with my watching of The Power of the Doctor. I watched it, on my own from the BBC iplayer, over four nights in April 2024, stopping at the end of each approximately 22-minute long quarter. Like those stories in the 1980s, the arbitrary cliffhangers were a little more pedestrian than usual, but none were as bad as the ones in The Five Doctors (the Master walks down a short staircase - woo!). My Power of the Doctor episode one ended with the Doctor seeing the defaced paintings and declaring "That's not Rasputin, that's the Master", the second ended just after the forced regeneration, with the Doctor now in the Master's form at the door of the TARDIS threatening Yaz; episode three ended with the eruption of the volcanoes around the world. That's not too bad, I don't think; each section fell into an episodic structure in line with those older Doctor Who stories: episode one is about the set up of the mystery, ending with the Doctor's discovery of the main adversary; episode two sees the plan develop and ends at the Doctor's lowest point; episode three throws in the curveball of the Guardians of the Edge; episode four wraps it all up.


Milestone watch: I've been blogging new and classic Doctor Who stories in random order since 2015, and I'm now closing in on the point where I finish everything and catch up with the current stories being broadcast serially. As well as finishing 24 of the 39 seasons to date (at the time of writing), I have also watched almost all of the specials that came in between seasons for anniversaries, festive periods, etc. With The Power of the Doctor now covered, there is only one special left to blog (The Giggle from 2023), though there will be at least one more Christmas special shown in 2024, and - one hopes - another annually thereafter.

First Time Round:
There was a period of only approximately 18 months between my writing this blog post and originally watching The Power of the Doctor, but it seemed like a lot longer looking back. I outlined my initial reactions to the story in the Deeper Thoughts section of the contemporaneous blog post for Orphan 55, which I published two days after the Jodie Whittaker finale was first shown. It was a time of upheaval in the UK; we had in short order got ourselves a new monarch and a new Prime Minister (I'll touch a bit more on this in the Deeper Thoughts section below). The change of Doctor happening at the same time felt like it might destabilise us completely, but thankfully things have been a bit more static and calm for old Albion since then under the firm and strong leadership of David Tennant and Ncuti Gatwa.


Reaction:
Brace yourselves, but - as outlined in this story - the power of the Doctor is the friends she made along the way. Yaz has a line of dialogue that pretty much says this verbatim, and the action involves a lot of people coming together to save the day who all have in common that their lives have been touched by the Doctor. It then has a resolution scene at the end bringing even more of the Doctor's old friends together to look after each other, and most importantly to look after the latest in the long line of ex-companions Yaz, adjusting to her post-TARDIS life. The friends she made along the way - it's so hackneyed that its gone beyond cliche and into meme, but the story doesn't for a moment let the commitment to this theme slip. Even the antagonist is driven by the misguided desire that he wants to become the Doctor and travel the universe with a companion; like everything in the story, this is nicely aligned with the history of the series. There's always been something of the inferiority complex about the Master, living in the Doctor's shadow. The plan also involving mucking about with Daleks, Cybermen, volcanoes and paintings is less resonant to this theme of course, but is still in keeping with The Power of the Doctor's hectic style in trying to cram in as many returning characters and elements as possible. In total, and including the regenerated fourteenth Doctor with a new old face, there are seven returning Doctors. No less than six companions return, seven if you count Dan who leaves at the start of the story but returns at the end (three are cameos including one of the very first stars of the show from 1963, William Russell as Ian Chesterton).


There's two recurring guest characters (Kate Lethbridge-Stewart and Vinder) and the top three on the Doctor Who villainy chart are represented, including the latest incarnation of the Master and a recent recurring Cyberman villain, Ashad. It has clearly been written with an understanding of its place in the canon of multi-Doctor stories; weaving in all those Doctors, companions and foes almost out-Five Doctors The Five Doctors; the missing paintings and involvement of UNIT is reminiscent of The Day of the Doctor. The story was an extra commission from the BBC to form part of the Corporation's centenary celebrations (which aside from this special Doctor Who story were rather muted in the end), so perhaps it was irresistible to include a lot of the programme's history (it having endured for nearly 60 of the Beeb's 100 years by then). It's not just a multi-Doctor celebration story, though, it is the final send off for Jodie Whittaker's Doctor - was there not felt to be a risk that her swansong would be overshadowed by all these returning elements? I doubt writer and executive producer Chris Chibnall was planning to have Whittaker regenerate at the end of a Sea Devils story; Legend of the Sea Devils looks to be the story that had been hastily added to the schedule at the last minute to bump up the numbers. As far as I can see, though, it has never been confirmed exactly how much of Power's planning and scripting had been done before the request came in to provide a centenary special.


My guess is that nothing was forced upon him, and Chibnall always planned such a story to write out his Doctor; it's a bold move, and it pays off. The character of the thirteenth Doctor has always been one that surrounds herself with a large 'fam', so the gang show approach does not jar. Whittaker doesn't suffer too much from a lack of screentime, and her presence - and her absence - dominates. It's a story of what it's like to be with, or be without, the Doctor. Making it seem effortless, Whittaker embodies the Doctor in the abstract and the specific, and everything else in the story is in orbit around her. Considering all the disparate elements to be combined in the final narrative, the plotting hangs together well. The only bit I'm still scratching my head over is forced regeneration; I understand it conceptually, but the visual of it doesn't align with the intention of the character. If the Master wants to be the Doctor, shouldn't he force a regeneration on himself, making him become her, not the other way round? This would have given Whittaker a chance to do something different, playing the evil villain for a part of the running time, and would have upped the ante when the Master is trying to destroy the Doctor's reputation: anything evil he did would have been done by someone who looks like our Doctor. If he wants to travel the universe looking like Sacha Dhawan accompanied by Yaz, then he could just kill the Doctor and steal her TARDIS, after all. Of course, this story is the swansong of Sacha Dhawan's Master too, and depriving viewers of even a second of his colossal, fantastic, unhinged performance might seem like sacrilege. He'd still be indelibly stamped onto the history of Doctor Who just for the Boney M scene, mind: the Master throwing shapes and Cossack dance moves to the 1978 Euro-Disco hit Rasputin, while a Dalek and a Cyberman look on askance.


There's also the wonderful conceit of the Master using famous paintings as a calling card - the visual of a Rasputin-disguised Master in The Scream or Girl with a Pearl Earring is a joy to behold. Rasputin's historical reputation (mesmeric powers, can't be killed) makes him an obvious choice as a Master alias; what's startling and perhaps genius about this is that there is no need for him to be disguised at all (in fact it would make much more sense for all the action to happen in the present day rather than split between 1916 and 2022) - the Master presumably just thought it would be funny. Again, this is in keeping with the character's actions in the history of the show. Apart from the Master's unnecessary disguises, the other two major returns from 1980s Who are Tegan and Ace. For everyone like me, who first got into the show when Peter Davison became the Doctor, this is every bit as exciting and important as Sarah Jane Smith coming back in School Reunion, only double. The script nails the older versions of their characters perfectly. Any fan would have to have a heart of petrified steel lava not to get a bit emotional seeing both reunited with holographic versions of their Doctors. The Guardians of the Edge sequence allows some more fun cameos - David Bradley, Colin Baker, Paul McGann! Fans of a more recent vintage would be well served too; Vinder and Ashad come back, having appeared in recent seasons. Then Graham pops up. Seeing people from different eras working together is pure, distilled Five Doctors juice ("I'm Ace", "Yes, you are" says Graham). Just when you think the story might be cameo-ed out, there's Jo Martin being the Doctor one last time too. Once the story's almost over, you get another few for good luck: Katy Manning as Jo Jones, Bonnie Langford as Mel, and - I'm getting a bit emotional again - William Russell as Ian Chesterton.


With David Tennant appearing at the end, that's at least one returning face from every decade of Doctor Who's existence; if you aren't charitable enough to give it anything else, that's an almighty triumph of logistics at least. The story seems to me to be more of a piece with the three specials in 2023 than the ones preceding it in 2022. Taken together, the four stories from The Power of the Doctor to The Giggle are the ultimate celebration of the show's history and set-up for its future. Even small details like the blowing up of UNIT HQ ("I'd only just signed the lease") fit nicely, allowing Kate-Lethbridge Stewart to move into Tony Stark's Avengers Tower the following year. Also distancing The Power of the Doctor from the rest of 2022 is that there's nothing in there about Yaz's feelings for the Doctor, which had been highlighted in both of the previous two specials. I can just about buy that they've both made their peace with things after the conversation in Legend of the Sea Devils, but I still think that it should have been Yaz's decision to part from the Doctor before she changes into someone new, rather than the Doctor essentially telling her to sling her hook. The emotional arc of the piece is restored by the 'companion's anonymous' scenes at the end, though: we know Yaz's is going to be looked after. Finally, there's the most beautiful regeneration sequence in the history of the show thus far: the Doctor atop Durdle Door with energy shooting far, far out in every direction. Then, we're off again, zooming into a bright, shiny future...

Connectivity:
Despite their broadcasts being separated by 35 years both The Power of the Doctor and Paradise Towers feature the Doctor played by Sylvester McCoy, and Mel played by Bonnie Langford. Echoing the action in the 1980s story, the UNIT building escape in the 21st century story involves heroic characters travelling to the highest floor of a skyscraper building in order to escape metallic killers (these adversaries move a bit faster, though).


Deeper Thoughts:
Two Yorkshire women with blonde bobs leave their job in the same week: Fit the Second. (Note: for Fit the First, of which this is the late-following sequel, see the Deeper Thoughts section of the Orphan 55 post from October 2022  - link in the First Time Round section above.)

The UK's politics was so turbulent in 2022 that the wikipedia entry that comes up when one searches on 'UK government crisis October 2022' has a link at the top that says - I kid you not - "This article is about the crisis that ended Liz Truss's premiership. For the crisis that ended Boris Johnson's premiership, see July 2022 United Kingdom government crisis", emphasis mine. In the UK, it was the year of three prime ministers, and - with Whittaker turning to Tennant, and it being common knowledge that Gatwa was waiting in the wings - the year of three Doctors too. After Johnson and Truss came Rishi Sunak; it's not that Sunak was exactly competent, but just by not being a clown car on fire he managed to usher in a period of relative stability. Was that local political turbulence followed by relative calm echoed somehow in the world of Doctor Who at the time? A lot of fans are very critical of the run for which showrunner Chris Chibnall was responsible, the stories from 2018 up to 2022 and The Power of the Doctor. Putting aside any subjective judgements about the quality of the stories (and there were times in those years reading fan discussions on the internet that I hoped like hell that people would put aside their subjective judgements about the quality of the stories) the production of the show did face more challenges than at any other time in its history. For a start, the world outside the show, that at some level needed to be reflected in the stories - Doctor Who always counterpointing its far-out space action with the recognisable and the grounded - was changing very rapidly.


This can clearly be seen in the story Revolution of the Daleks, a festive special shown on the 1st January 2021. The story was made as part of the series that aired a year earlier, with filming happening in the autumn of 2019, and the script was presumably written a while before that. The character of politician Jo Patterson, played by Harriet Walter, is ruthlessly fixated on public order and then becomes prime minister, so has too many things in common with Theresa May to be coincidental. May, though, had been out of power for nearly 18 months by the time Revolution of the Daleks got to an audience. As we saw above, May was just one of three prime ministers during Chibnall's time (with only a hair's breadth from it being four), so it was hard for scripting to keep up with real life; perhaps connected to some of that governmental instability was the biggest impact to the making of the show in this period, the Covid-19 virus. No matter what else was depicted in the story, it couldn't have predicted lockdowns, mask-wearing, vaccines and Joe Wicks TV workouts. It feels a bit unfair of fate that Chibnall didn't get to make more Doctor Who when the restrictions were eased, but he left at a time of his own choosing, and went out with a bang with The Power of the Doctor. It's a story in which you'd be hard pressed to discern any compromises indicative of it having been made in the aftermath of a pandemic. That he made any Doctor Who at all after Revolution of the Daleks, let alone such bold and brash and visually impressive fare as Flux and the 2022 specials, is a source of wonder to me. Once he'd left and Russell T Davies had taken up the showrunner job again, though, the money really started to flow and even greater things became possible.


Imagine if Chibnall were to comment publicly during Davies's period in charge, talking loudly and constantly about how he could do better? He'd never do such a crass thing, of course, and probably never want to do it. The world of television production seems to be more polite and honourable than the world of politics, because no such restraint exists there. In April 2024, Liz Truss - one of those quick-changing 2022 prime ministers and architect of one of the aforementioned 2022 crises - published a book with her plan to "Save the West", and was on the interview circuit expounding on said plan. Liz Truss was prime minister for 50 days. For a chunk of that short time, party political activity was suspended because of the funeral of the monarch, otherwise it might have been even shorter. She crashed financial markets and lost control of her own MPs in the space of a very few weeks, and her tenure ended in utter failure. With that track record, for her to have the sheer gall to lecture anyone on how to run anything is another source of wonder to me. I'm not equating her dismal record in any way with Chibnall's; whatever you think of the quality of his work, though, you know and I know that he's never going to publish a book on his plan to save Doctor Who, and will only ever say positive things about his successor. I sense a part of online Doctor Who fandom wants the Truss approach, however; and that, base and lowest common denominator as it is, she's scratching a similar itch in politics fans on a certain stripe.


If you like one showrunner more than another, it can get pretty tribal in the rarefied atmosphere of social media sites. When Steven Moffat took over from Davies, I read a lot of posts by people who imagined that Moffat was sneaking in references in his stories that took pot shots at the previous house style. They were convinced that he was in some way critical of Davies, even though there was no evidence of this in any of his public pronouncements. Moffat has hopefully, finally, put that to bed by agreeing to come back as a hired hand (he's writing the third story in Davies's first Ncuti Gatwa season, Boom). For anyone that might be imagining that Davies has any issues with his immediate predecessor, I'd direct you to the comments he makes in Doctor Who Magazine issue 603 about the controversial Timeless Child plotline that Chibnall introduced to Who and which Davies is developing further in Gatwa's episodes: "That's a gift handed to me by my predecessor... it's an honour to take it on from him" and "There's so much story in it!". Maybe we could all take a lesson from this interconnected and respectful approach when it comes to Doctor Who and to politics. Liz Truss knows that she's unlikely ever to hold high office again, but she will have seen from certain UK populists of recent times, who have made a living of sniping from the sidelines while not having the responsibility of any direct power, that this doesn't mean she can't have influence. It is telling that a lot of the interviews she gave in April 2024 were aimed at the hyper-partisan US; without extreme polar opposite tribes, who possibly don't represent the nuanced reality that sits between the poles, many negative things - including online Doctor Who flame wars and Truss's book - might not need to exist.

In Summary:
The Power of the Doctor was inside of us all along!