Showing posts with label season 25. Show all posts
Showing posts with label season 25. Show all posts

Thursday, 9 February 2023

The Greatest Show in the Galaxy

Chapter the 255th, where we discover much evidence of coulrophobia and lycanthropy, and the Doctor displays his legerdemain.


Plot:
The Doctor and Ace receive an aggressive junk mail bot in the TARDIS advertising a talent show run by the Psychic Circus on the planet Segonax. Despite her fear of clowns, Ace agrees to go with the Doctor. On the planet, they meet colourful characters all bound for the circus tent to take part in the talent show: aggressive biker Nord, insufferably pompous adventurer Captain Cook and his mysterious young companion Mags, and Whizz Kid, the number one fan of the Psychic Circus. The place is a bit run down now, and only appears to have one family (a Dad, Mum, and child) in the audience; plus, the Chief Clown, Ringmaster and fortune-teller Morgana seem to be in thrall of some force. This is perhaps connected with the mysterious stones in the circus ring area - the tent has been put up around the ruins of a temple to an ancient power. The Captain plays other people against each other, getting them to be the next ones to perform in the ring, and Nord and Whizz Kid are killed there when they can no longer entertain.

Escaping, the Doctor and Ace separately and together piece together the backstory. In the past, Kingpin, the then leader of the Circus, believed he could harness the powers on Segonax and used a special medallion to do this. Unfortunately, the power was too strong and seemed to burn out Kingpin's mind, though he can be restored if the medallion is ever made whole again. The jewelled eye from the centre of the medallion was hidden, and the remaining members served the ancient power, the Gods of Ragnarok (who appear in the Circus's time-space in the form of the family of three). Some of the Circus folk tried to escape and find the eye, but were killed. With no acts left to go in the ring, the Captain, Doctor and Mags appear together. With a moon-shaped lighting effect, the Captain instigates Mags's transformation into a werewolf; he plans to take control of the Circus's power himself. The Doctor manages to entreat Mag's inner self, and she turns instead on the Captain and kills him, then returns to normal. The Doctor faces off against the Gods of Ragnarok, who have by now killed almost everyone else, while Ace, Mags and Kingpin find the jewelled eye and bring the Doctor the full medallion. With its power, he destroys the Gods of Ragnarok and the Circus.


Context:
This story completes another full season blogged, making season 25 the eighth one completed (following seasons 3, 8, 14, 17, 23, and new series 6 and 13); it was watched across two weekends in January and February 2023, two episodes a week, from the DVD (this is - at the time of writing - the most recently broadcast Doctor Who television story not yet available on Blu-ray, and I wondered when watching it how it might scrub up when released on that medium in future). I was accompanied both times by all three children (boys of 16 and 13, girl of 10). It didn't quite hold everyone's attention to the very end, though the youngest was very impressed by the conjuring tricks the Doctor does in episode four. Everyone was critical - excessively, to my mind - of the effects sequence of the juggling club falling into the mysterious well. I find this interesting in regards to different levels of suspension of disbelief: they didn't doubt the depiction of a cosmic, chasmic well with an eye looking up from bottom, just an object falling a bit awkwardly into it. 

First Time Round:
Season 25 was scheduled to start only after the completion of the BBC's coverage of the 1988 Olympics in Seoul, so its finale The Greatest Show in the Galaxy aired later in the year than usual. Doctor Who's seasons at the time were usually done and dusted early in December, but this one snuck into the Yuletide schedules, with two episodes in the run up to the big day and two within the 12 days of Christmas. This meant that I saw The Talons of Weng-Chiang for the first time slap-bang in the middle of the story (having received the video as a Christmas present on the 25th December 1988 - see the First Time Round section of this blog post for more details). The final episode did not air until 1989, on January 4th. For the previous one on 28th December, my Mum dragged my sister and me, both of us somewhat unwilling, to her friend's house down the road, as we'd been invited for a meal during the festive season. Trying to get out of going, I'd said that I really wanted to watch that evening's episode of Doctor Who as it went out live; that was no problem, I was told, as the friend's kids wanted to watch it anyway. So it came to pass that the 16-year old me crammed himself onto the sofa with a seven- and a five-year old to watch Sylvester McCoy battle against robot clowns. I was already slightly embarrassed, but it got worse when every adult in attendance guffawed their way through the sequence at the end of the episode where Mags transforms into a werewolf. They laughed and laughed, thinking it hilarious. I tried to disappear into the sofa, but that isn't easy when you're going crimson and radiating heat. In those days, when every episode clashed with the much more popular Coronation Street, viewing Doctor Who was almost always a solitary activity; I only appreciated the advantages of that once I'd watched Greatest Show part three with other people.


Reaction:
The end of that third episode of the story is excellently realised, whatever some of the people I first watched it with (see First Time Round section) thought. Even better is the continuation of the sequence in the final part. It starts in the dark comic vein of previous characters' appearances in the ring, turns to well handled family-friendly Doctor Who horror as Mags transforms into an 80s post-punk werewolf, then moves into a full-on choreographed action sequence where the Captain cracks a whip, lion tamer style, using Mags as a weapon against the Doctor who's desperately trying to escape. Within this energetic sequence, the plot still moves forward - the Captain monologues his plan to take over the power of the Circus, the alien nature of the spectating family of three is revealed - and there's some nice moments like the cutaways to the family raising their scorecards, each giving the spectacle before them a 9, or to the lamp in the lighting rig spinning madly as Mags turns on and savages the Captain. It works for me, but I can see how it might not for another viewer because, well, it has an 80s post-punk werewolf and a bloke in a pith helmet cracking a whip, surrounded by circus performers. A key strength of the story is the incongruity of the imagery, with playful but eerie juxtapositions like a silent hearse driven through a barren landscape by a clown in an undertaker's outfit. The characters are all larger than life and their looks emblematic rather than realistic (there's no Martin Smith from Croydon here, it's all Nord The Vandal and Whizz Kid and the like).


As a teenager watching the opening of part one, I felt a bit of trepidation. The story was called "The Greatest Show in the Galaxy" rather than something more traditional, and the opening scene is Ricco Ross's Ringmaster doing a rap. In 1988, a UK show featuring anyone rapping was generally to be avoided as a near-certain embarrassment. (It turned out alright though; Mark Ayres' music underpinning all the Ringmaster's raps is rather good, as is his work throughout the serial, and Ross's close-up look to camera at the end nicely sinister.) If even a long-term fan like me needed a bit of time to acclimatise to this story world, perhaps it wasn't a surprise that non-fans coming into it cold at episode three might struggle with the overload of seemingly silly visual elements. This was perhaps the start of a different style of Doctor Who for a video-recording audience, where there's significantly more service given to those watching every episode than those just casually dropping in here and there (this approach would be furthered in 1989's season 26). Countering that theory, though, is the surprising fact that episode four got the biggest audience of Sylvester's three years as the Doctor, with almost a million more people than usual tuning in, forgoing Coronation Street on the other side. It wasn't to do with Christmas scheduling either - the third part had one of the lowest ratings for story and season, lost in the festive noise. But the final episode, appearing at the start of a new year, proved to be a draw.


Those tuning in that week would have seen perhaps the best sequence of this era, and a defining moment for Sylvester as the Doctor: his stroll out of the chaos of the collapsing circus that then explodes behind him, walking away without reacting or breaking stride. It's just one of a number of great character moments for the regulars. Sophie Aldred as Ace is perhaps a little less well served by the script than Sylv - it errs a little too much on telling us that she doesn't like clowns rather than showing us - but it's a minor quibble. The script is giving the companion material with more emotion and depth than had been done for a while before this story, something again that would be developed in future. The two lead characters look to be at the height of their powers here, though again it just kept getting better the following year. It's hard to believe this is only their third story together (it was produced second in the run but shown fourth). The guest cast are uniformly good too. Jessica Martin as Mags is a good would-be companion, Dee Sadler makes a big impression as the doomed Flowerchild even though her character is gone early on in episode one, Christopher Guard plays Bellboy with sensitivity, and gets one of this era's greatest death scenes, committing suicide by turning his own robot creations on himself. Best of all is Ian Reddington as the Chief Clown. There's not much to the character on the page, but he perfects every little gesture, expression and changes in tone of voice to make a memorable and effective villain.


Stories in Sylvester McCoy's tenure tend to love ensembles, but - even with a great group of actors as there is here - a cast is only as good as the material they are given. Greatest Show has fun adventure, an intriguing mystery, and engaging world building. What lifts it up to an even higher level of quality is its underlying theme. There is an interesting subtext about the decline and death of western counter-cultural movements from their emergence in the 1960s (as represented by the nomadic and commune-like existence of the Psychic Circus before arriving on Segonax) to the point in the late 1980s when the story was made and when everyone seemed to be selling out to unfettered capitalism (as represented by settling on Segonax and keeping the demanding audience of the Gods of Ragnarok entertained). It's an original theme for Doctor Who, and an interesting slant on subject matter the show at this time came back to again and again, critiquing the heartlessness of the Thatcherite era in the UK. The only issue is that no money ever changes hands in the Psychic Circus (the enterprising stallholder and Segonax native played by Peggy Mount, of whom Margaret Thatcher would no doubt have been proud, is the only person seen to expect payment). Even the closest reading is likely therefore to connote that its the consumers that are the problem, not the capitalists, that the antagonism is coming from an insatiable audience, rather than an evil commissioning director or studio bigwig trying to make a buck. Though any writer would empathise with the story's author Stephen Wyatt if he despaired at having to continually feed the hungry story consumption machine, I think this is inadvertent. It's just a shame that a story that found an audience also seemed to be taking pot shots at it.


Connectivity:
Both this story and the last one blogged feature posters (the wartime Dalek 'Victory' poster in Victory of the Daleks, and the many examples advertising the tours of the Psychic Circus in The Greatest Show in the Galaxy); they each also feature antagonists made of metal, one of a pair of lovers coming to a tragic end leaving the other one sad, and a reference to someone with the rank of Captain.

Deeper Thoughts:
The Fan in Fiction. The character of Whizz Kid in The Greatest Show in the Galaxy caused some eyebrows to be raised in the audience, as he was clearly a fictional representation of a science fiction fan of the sort that might obsess over Doctor Who. He was there as an in-jokey dig at those watching who might take the programme a bit too seriously. Even though I saw myself being sent up, I still found this fun; others, though, were probably more annoyed. What all of us probably missed was that the character was notable in another way: I've wracked my brains and I can't think of an earlier depiction of such a fan on UK television. It might well be a first. Beatlemania and Dalekmania both exploded in the UK in the mid 1960s, and England won the men's football world cup in 1966. In the period from then through the 1970s and into the 1980s, characters who were pop music fans and football fans were not uncommon in comedies or dramas, but sci-fi or telefantasy enthusiasts, not at all. Part of this may be that stories have to attempt to be interesting, and screen stories attempt to express this interest visually. Pop music and football fans get out of the house and go places to indulge their fandom; there's not much for a writer to mine from someone just happily watching TV.  For fans to be fictionalised, there needed to be Fandom (with a capital 'F'), and this was slow getting going. The first Star Trek convention, getting fans out of the house and away from their television sets, was early in the 1970s (1972, to be exact), but the first for Doctor Who was much nearer the end of the decade (1977). After that, it would take another decade for this subcultural activity to be known and acknowledged enough for writer and audience in order for a fictional Doctor Who fan to appear on screen.


Early in the 1980s, Gian Sammarco portrayed Adrian Mole on UK television, in an adaptation of Sue Townsend's books. His casting as Whizz Kid was a meta-textual hint at the similarities of the characters; Mole, though, is much more the embodiment of an older tradition of lovelorn teenager and wannabe poet. This same character type was satirised by Rik Mayall around the same time as the 'People's Poet' in The Young Ones, and is still going strong today with Matthew Baynton as Thomas in Ghosts representing. For a character who is perhaps less interested in girls and poetry but who definitely knows Yeoman Rand's cabin number, the first significant depiction I can find is the infamous 'Get a Life' sketch from US TV's Saturday Night Live in 1986. William Shatner guest stars delivering some home truths to a group of nerds at a Star Trek convention. It's more about the cult TV star than the fans though; the latter are very crudely drawn and act as a mass of antagonism demanding detailed answers from the Shat about an acting job he did two decades earlier. It's not very nice to or for anyone involved (I've always thought Shatner's line to the assembled fans of "Look at the way you're dressed" was a bit rich seeing as he appears to be wearing an outfit made of a fake polyester bear rug in the skit). The Whizz Kid's treatment is affectionate by comparison. A UK TV descendent of the sketch is 2003's Cruise of the Gods, a TV movie written by Tim Firth starring Rob Brydon. He plays the former lead of a fictional Sci-Fi TV show, The Children of Castor, again beset by crudely drawn fans wanting something from him that he can't give.


The fans in such stories are not characters in their own right, but devices, stereotypes. Possibly too, they are not even realistic ones. Glimpses of The Children of Castor shown in Cruise of the Gods demonstrate - for the purposes of exaggerated comedy - that it's not a show anyone would want to watch, let alone remember. This damages the reality of its story world a bit. It's therefore preferable to feature a real show if you can, so any adoration, even if potentially misplaced, can at least seem credible. (Aside: would selected clips from The Greatest Show in the Galaxy taken out of context look as naff as the bits of Castor seen in Cruise of the Gods? Let's not dwell on that.)  As the 1990s progressed, fictional fans of real programmes and films became more and more common. A prestigious series like Alan Bleasdale's GBH contained scenes where a character is surrounded by the chaos of a Doctor Who convention, attended by many cosplayers, happening in the hotel in which he's staying. In Queer as Folk, Russell T Davies combines the lovelorn archetype with a Doctor Who fan in the character of Vince, drawing on his own detailed fan knowledge for specifics to add verisimilitude. Then there was Spaced, The IT Crowd, The Big Bang Theory, Community (which used a fictionalised version of what was obviously Doctor Who in its show within a show, Inspector Spacetime), and Galaxy Quest on the big screen (which used a fictionalised version of what was obviously Star Trek, presumably so they didn't get sued).


The other thing that's required to make a story interesting, of course, is conflict. What's heartening is that after a few decades, the conflict in the lives of sci-fi fan characters is rarely between them and their favourite show: it's not a barrier to them engaging with and enjoying other parts of life (don't get me wrong, the characters usually do have barriers stopping them from enjoying other parts of life, but the fact that they like shows featuring aliens is incidental). What is intriguing about Whizz Kid is that there's only one place from where conflict arises. He's a generally very happy and positive person, admits a tiny misgiving "Although I never got to see the early days, I know it's not as good as it used to be but I'm still terribly interested" (which is a dig against Doctor Who fans that relied too much on received wisdom, but shows the character to be relatively thoughtful and open). Then, the show that he likes and the people involved in its production destroy him. Morgana, working the circus's front of house, tries to dissuade others from going in, knowing their eventual fate. After a few minutes in Whizz Kid's company, though, she ushers him in gladly. I can't find anything on record about whose idea the character was; I suspect Stephen Wyatt might have been prompted to include him by either script editor Andrew Cartmel or producer John Nathan-Turner, who both had more experience of organised Doctor Who fandom. Even if I'm wrong, both those gentlemen would have signed off on the final scripts. Did they think about what this was saying? In a story that already had a subtext hinting that the mass viewership were monsters that had to be constantly fed, there's also a giant middle finger given to the minority fan audience: the makers hate them and wish they were dead. Justice for Whizz Kid!

In Summary:
An enjoyable, well-made and successful Doctor Who story whose subtext is (inadvertently?) telling its audience to get stuffed.

Tuesday, 22 September 2020

Remembrance of the Daleks



Chapter The 165th, which sees a return to some unfinished business


Plot:
The Doctor left some unfinished business in 1963 Shoreditch, the time and place where he was based for a few months many years back, with the TARDIS in a junkyard and his granddaughter Susan enrolled in the nearby Coal Hill school. Recently becoming aware that the Daleks were following him, out to obtain a Time Lord superweapon - the Hand of Omega -  he'd left there, he leads them back. However, he hadn't anticipated two factions of Daleks, the Imperial and the Renegade groups. Teaming up with Group Captain Gilmore and his team, a sort of proto-UNIT, the Doctor endeavours to stop the humans getting killed while the Daleks fight amongst themselves. The Renegade faction obtains the Hand of Omega, with help from a schoolkid wired into a Dalek battle computer and a local neo-Mosleyite group called the Association.


One of Gilmore's soldiers, Mike, has been feeding information to this Association, and it just so happens he's the very same squaddie that Ace has taken a shine to: rule 1 of Doctor Who, anyone Ace fancies will probably betray everyone. He gets killed soon after, anyway, as is customary. The Imperial Daleks bring out their big guns, well, big gun singular, really - the Special Weapons Dalek. It helps them defeat the other faction and make off to their mothership with the Hand. Davros reveals himself to be the new emperor of the Daleks, and the Doctor - having lashed up the 1960s tech equivalent of a Zoom call - broadcasts to the mothership, advising Davros not to use the Hand. Davros takes no notice, of course, and the Hand destroys the Dalek fleet and their home planet Skaro.



Context:

Like the Doctor in Remembrance, I too am returning to unfinished business. After a summer holiday (staying at home), I took a short break from doing the blog for the rest of August and the start of September. But during that time I had watched two stories which needed to be written up. After watching The Lodger on my own, youngest child (girl of 8) requested a specific story, which she described as the one where the girl beats up the Dalek with a baseball bat. She's not seen it before, but the Better Half has talked about it to her previously. Over the many years I've been doing the blog, I don't think she has ever requested a story, so I was happy to override the randomiser to allow this. The whole family - Better Half and youngest being joined by myself and two boys (aged 14 and 11) - watched an episode a night from the revisited special edition DVD. It's taken a while to get back to the notes I took and write them up for the blog. That's not to say I haven't been watching Doctor Who in the meantime, of course; I have been working my way through a lot of animated Pat Troughton goodness, the new improved special edition of Power of the Daleks, and the recently released Fury from the Deep (I'll try to find an appropriate point in a future blog post to share some mini-reviews of those).


First time round:

I'll inevitably and rightly need to discuss below in my review of the story the kind of impact it had when it was first shown, as it is an intrinsic part of every viewing of the story even to this day. But there is an anecdote to tell about my own very first encounter with episode 2, or half of it at least. I don't think it's giving too much away to say I'd been blown away by the first episode on its debut UK broadcast. A week later, on the 12th October 1988, a few hours before it was shown, I was looking forward to seeing the second part; this was the point at which my sister decided to play a trick on me. She systematically went round our house changing the time on every clock, putting them all forward to the time of Doctor Who's BBC1 slot. Then, she played my tape of the Doctor Who theme, loudly, on the home hi-fi in the living room (where the TV also was). The idea was that I would come running thinking that Doctor Who had started, and I was missing it. I came running instead as I was intrigued why anyone in the house would be playing the Doctor Who theme who wasn't me. My sister hadn't counted on my extreme nerdiness in being able to tell the difference between the Peter Howell arrangement (on the tape) and the Keff McCulloch arrangement (on the current episodes) from fifty paces. 


The joke was on me in the end though, as I failed to reset any of the clocks, nor work out exactly how fast they all now were. I was then distracted by my other lifelong obsession apart from Doctor Who, the music of the Pet Shop Boys. Their album Introspective had come out at the beginning of that week, and I was at the time listening to it over and over again on my personal stereo in my room (quite rightly, too, it's brilliant). Returning to this activity after my sister's trick, I lost track of time completely, and couldn't rely on any clocks around me either. Had I not had a new PSB album, I'd have been watching TV in the run up to the episode, poised to start the video recording. As it was, sometime during my third or fourth time marvelling at the piano break in Frankie Knuckles' remix of I Want a Dog, I was suddenly jerked into the realisation of how late it was getting. Rushing into the living room, I jabbed at the VCR's record button in time to catch the last 15 minutes or so of the episode. The first thing I saw was a split second of Joseph Marcell, playing an unknown character, disappearing out of shot. 



I'd missed the resolution of the cliffhanger, some action scenes and what later became a famous and lauded scene of Sylvester McCoy as the Doctor and Joseph Marcell as John - the latter later to become famous as the butler in the Fresh Price of Bel-Air - talking about slavery in a late-night caff. Asking my friends at Sixth Form the next day wasn't much help in filling in the gaps, bagging me as it did threadbare explanations along the lines of "A soldier turned up at the school with big guns" and "The Doctor had a chat with a bloke about sugar". It was five more years before I saw that missing section, when the VHS of the story was first released in the Dalek tin, the first ever Doctor Who home video release to come in such a container (there would be many more). I still have the tin, but - unlike the others, which I've also kept - it's got a bit rusty since 1993. 


Reaction:

Luckily my sister didn't play any tricks on me (see above) one week earlier. The beginning of episode 1 of Remembrance of the Daleks is not one you would want to miss. The BBC globe ident faded out and another image of the globe of the Earth hanging in space faded in (nice little formal gag, probably intentional?); every fan in the audience will be automatically aware that we are seeing a pre-credits sequence, a rarity during the 'classic Who' years - this would be only the fourth time it had ever been done, and the last time before the show was resurrected in 1996 and 2005 onwards. If those watching were clued in already that what was to follow would be a bit special, they wouldn't have been wrong. We hear snatches of speeches of 1963 vintage "I have a dream", "Ich bin ein Berliner", etc. coming in and out like a radio being tuned. A tense, but still energetic music cue comes in (part of what is probably Keff McCulloch's most successful incidental score for the series). It's an excellent model shot of the earth, and as the scene continues and builds, the shot zooms out and we see an alien spacecraft heading sleekly and ominously toward the planet. Bang - we're into the beginning credits. I'm going to go out on a limb and say that I think that it is the best opening few seconds of any Doctor Who story up to that point. Simple; cheap, even, but damned effective. Could the rest of the story live up to this early promise?



Yes, is the short answer. The rest of this blog text is a slightly longer way of saying it, but it is but one of a chorus of such reactions, longer and more detailed from all across fandom and for years since it was first shown. In Doctor Who magazine polls of all the broadcast stories to date, Remembrance made the top ten in 1998 and 2014 (it was slightly relegated in the intervening poll in 2009, but only dropped to number 14 of 200).  It stands on its own, but for those of us who were watching around the time it is probably inextricable from its context at that moment. The last story shown before this, the final episode of the previous year, Dragonfire, was a good enough script, and had some good performances and a few good effects. At the time, I'd latched upon it as the most traditional, and probably best executed story of the year. But it's so outclassed by Remembrance, that the difference is like night and day. But in one of those extreme North Scandi areas where the night lasts for months. It felt like a long time since we'd had a story so good and so self-assured. To me, it was the best story since The Caves of Androzani, four years previously, and - with no hyperbole, I assure you - the best Dalek story since the 1960s.


With Davros hidden for most of the action, the Daleks get to dominate the story in a way that they hadn't in their more recent previous outings, where they were playing second fiddle to their creator. And, by restating their xenophobia in a fresh new way, contrasting it with the racism (both casual and full-on neo-Nazi) of some of the human characters in the 1960s setting, Doctor Who's biggest baddies are revitalised. It doesn't hurt that the props are revitalised too. The Daleks themselves, and all their tech - including a full-size shuttle craft - gleam, and it's nice to see innovation too, with the Special Weapons Dalek being a memorable creation that lived on in viewers' imaginations, finally making a cameo appearance in the new series (in Asylum of the Daleks). The colour schemes of both factions are great (gold and white Daleks led by an Emperor based on the old 1960s comic strip look, and grey and black Daleks, led by a traditional black and silver Supreme Dalek). The idea of two factions is a complicating factor to allow the narrative to fill its running time interestingly, and allows some comments on the Daleks warring over racial purity, but it also extends the mythology of the series admirably. The last time we saw Davros, he'd created a new race of  gold and white Daleks, and was taken off - by grey and black Daleks - to stand trial. Somehow, the wily Davros has turned the tables sufficiently that he has once again managed to take charge, and his old captors have become the renegade splinter group. It's not spelled out, it's just there as a nice bit of world-building for the fans, allowing imagination to flood into the gap (at least one tie-in medium has since written the story around that connecting narrative tissue).



It's not perfect, few things are, but any flaws are minor and seem to be borne out of ambition, so it's hard to criticise too much. For example, the concept of the battle computer (a child plugged into a Dalek-like casing) is an interesting and chilling one, and the child actor Jasmine Breaks performs it perfectly; it provides a nice shock reveal moment for anyone watching, but particularly for fans as every scene up to that point has been framed to suggest that it is Davros. It's let down, though, by the staging - the set or the prop in the room where George Sewell as Radcliffe is conversing with the computer should be constructed so that he can't see that there's a schoolgirl in there. And it isn't. He'd have to have zero peripheral vision and zero curiosity for it to be in any way credible. The writer Ben Aaronovitch, working on his first TV screenplay, is feeling his way. The feint about Davros, and the reveal of the girl were all in his screenplay as it developed, but he hadn't actually included Davros elsewhere until someone suggested people might wonder where he was.



Adding that particular character and another wonderful reveal in the final episode was welcome, but another minor flaw of Remembrance, shared with a lot of stories of this period, is that there were already too many characters chasing around for this week's cosmic MacGuffin. Pamela Salem and Karen Gledhill (as Professor Jensen and Alison respectively) are both great, but their characters contribute nothing to moving the narrative along. Simon Williams as Gilmore is the class act one would expect, but he doesn't do very much more. In fact, the whole cast is excellent, even down to the extended cameos from a couple of actors who kept coming back for guest spots in Doctor Who over the  years, Michael Sheard and Peter Halliday. The dialogue they're all given is nice and colourful, and they're directed well. It's just that they aren't needed really. The story boils down to a very simple bait and switch con trick that the Doctor is playing on Davros. Everyone and everything else that happens just defers that; but, the script makes something of a virtue of this - it's the dark chess-playing Doctor's finely tuned clockwork scheme being interfered with by humans and Daleks that won't quite play ball.



The performance of Sylvester McCoy to achieve the dark chess-playing Doctor is something else that's wonderful to behold. Though there are occasional flashes of a more thoughtful or brooding nature in the previous year's stories, that side of the character hadn't been very much explored; from here on in, the writing and the leading man's performance bring this expertly to the fore. Another new aspect that has been thoroughly embraced since the series went off air in 1987 is Doctor Who's long history. There's an excuse for it here, given that this is the opening salvo of a season that acts as an anniversary 25-gun salute, but forever after this point the Sylvester McCoy stories will be informed by, and build upon, without slavishly copying,  the show's established mythology. This is exemplified by the first ever sustained and successful depiction of a Dalek levitating up a flight of stairs. A triumph, and just one of many many magical moments in this superlative serial.

  

Connectivity: 

Remembrance of the Daleks and The Lodger both take place in the South of England, and both see the Doctor stay for a night or more in the house of one of the guest characters.




Deeper Thoughts:

This Time Machine Kills Fascists. Remembrance of the Daleks, the TV story, started a trend of the series being more socially conscious in its subtext, in highlighting modern racism through both a 1960s and a Dalek lens. Remembrance of the Daleks, the tie-in novelisation, published a few years after the broadcast, arguably continued that trend into a new medium and kicked off a whole new line of original Doctor Who novels, the New Adventures, that would continue Doctor Who's ongoing narrative in the years when the TV show was not being made. Aaronovitch, in adapting his own scripts for 1990 publication, was the first of the set of new young Doctor Who writers who'd recently written for the TV show to flesh out the world and characters of his story on the page to a much greater extent that had generally been done before. A year later in 1991, with no sign of Doctor Who returning to TV any time soon, Virgin started publishing a range of original novels. They'd been producing novelisations of broadcast stories before then, but were rapidly running out of those that hadn't been done already. Aaronovitch was again one of a group of writers - with pedigrees either in professional or fan-fiction Who work - involved in producing these original stories, "too broad and too deep for the small screen" as the cover blurb styled it. The range was featured in a number of articles in this month's Doctor Who Magazine (I'm not sure why now, though - holding off until next year would have meant they could have tied in with the 30th anniversary of the first book).



I remember when that first book (Timewyrm: Genesys by John Peel, but not that John Peel) came out. It was the summer before I started at university, and I snapped it up from my usual supplier of all things Who, Volume One in Worthing. The excitement wore off a bit quickly for me: the book isn't that great. The title being two not-quite words connected by a hyphen was not a good sign, but things were just starting out. Anyway, I was still only a beginner fan when it came to viewing old episodes. I didn't need new worlds of Doctor Who's ongoing narrative to explore, as I was diving into its history by dint of the VHS releases. I've probably given the impression talking about collecting the videos in blog posts passim  that I had unlimited funds in those days. I was certainly lucky, but alas I still had to count the pennies to an extent, and videos came first; so, I was never exhaustive in collecting the New Adventures novels. Later in the Summer, I bought the second one (Timewyrm: Exodus by Terrance Dicks) because Terrance Dicks. Thereafter, though, I was choosy. I managed to find a few second-hand in later uni years, in a Durham sci-fi emporium, amongst the many, many Red Dwarf T-shirts (it was the early 1990s, what are you going do?!). Then, I bought a few more new when I was working after graduation, but by then the range was almost at an end. 



Like anything established in the world of Doctor Who fandom, the New Adventures soon became a battleground. The main fault line that cleaved fandom in two was the 'Trad versus Rad' divide. In summary, all that social conscience and innovative, dangerous subject matter (i.e. sex and swearing) was loved by a certain group of regular authors and fans, but the other group (writers and fans alike) just wanted to tell an engaging story of the kind that Doctor Who used to tell on telly. As usual for an awkward sort, I didn't feel at home in either camp; I liked some of the the Trad stuff and some of the Rad. Sometimes, the Trad stuff did get a bit stodgy, and the Rad stuff did disappear up its own space-time vortex. The range - never really settling down into one style or the other - lasted until 1997; the Paul McGann TV movie's launch the previous year had prompted a general reboot of BBC Worldwide's Doctor Who products, and they brought the ongoing original novels in-house to be published thereafter by BBC Books (there wasn't much sex and swearing after that).



Another battleground in fandom that's emerged since is in discussions of the legacy of the New Adventures, and particularly what impact they had on the series when it came back onto television screens in 2005. Russell T Davies is his usual perceptive self when interviewed about this in the magazine, and makes many good points, but he downplays any influence. He's right in his point that the relatively inexperienced writers had things made easier for them by being given free rein; writing books (or indeed TV stories) that would appeal to a wide audience without offending material takes more discipline. It is true though, that the writers of the first return Doctor Who season in 2005 bar one had all written for Virgin, including Russell himself who had a New Adventure published (Damaged Goods in 1996). And  later, possibly the most successful of the New Adventures, Human Nature was adapted for TV on Russell's watch. Anyway, Russell T Davies can't throw stones about the lack of discipline in writing something with adolescent sex and swearing. We haven't forgotten series 1 of Torchwood, Russell; how could we?! 


In Summary:

Like a Dalek hovering up the stairs, this one rises up above any competition to be one of the very best the series has to offer.

Thursday, 13 September 2018

The Happiness Patrol

Chapter The 99th, wherein happiness may not prevail...

Plot: 
The Doctor takes Ace to a planet he's heard nasty rumours about, Terra Alpha, a human colony in the future where sadness is outlawed and everybody has to smile all the time. People get killed or  disappear at random by government order, and capitalism - or maybe communism - is represented by metaphors about sweets. The TARDIS team find quite a few allies (a bit too many, and too quickly given it's only three episodes long and set over the course of one evening, but there you go). Together they foment rebellion again the despot ruler Helen A, and her hench-robot made of sweets, the Kandyman. She's overthrown and finally cries over the death of her pet puppet dog-rat, Fifi.

Context:
I had high hopes for this one; it's popular with most fans of the Sylvester McCoy Doctor Whos, and - perhaps because of some of the over-stylised visuals, or the prominent satire - is well remembered by the casual viewers of the time as well: it's the only Doctor Who story to my knowledge to be mentioned, more than twenty years after broadcast, separately on Newsnight and in a speech by the Archbishop of Canterbury. It's fine as a memory, but how would it work to actually sit down and watch the episodes? I asked the Better Half to watch with me, and she was cautiously optimistic as I started up the DVD. McCoy was her childhood Doctor, and Ace her favourite companion. What could go wrong? Alas, dear reader, she bailed after one episode, and I watched the other two without her. Sample comments, or at least the repeatable ones, as follows: "Look at the shiny studio floor", "Crud!", "Why are we watching this?!", "Is it supposed to be noir? Call the Midwife is more noir than this,", and "It's just so awful." If she'd stayed the course, she may have found the final two episodes better - I definitely noticed an improvement. The kids joined me instead (daughter of 6 years old from episode 2, her brothers, aged 9 and 12, for the final part) and were not nearly so critical.

First-time round:
Why was home video-taping so difficult for some people in the 1980s? It can't have been just me, as there was a mini-industry of joke-telling on the subject involving stand-up comedians and sitcoms of the time. My memories of late 1980s Doctor Who are dotted with episodes that I tried to record but missed, or those where I only caught half, or those which I did record correctly but then accidentally got recorded over later because someone had rewound the tape a little. My first glimpse of The Happiness Patrol was shown on a Saturday morning kids show ('Going Live!' I assume) when Sylvester McCoy was being interviewed. I didn't - as many fans did - have a tape ready for such occasions to record these Who-related odds and sods - too inept to record things with no warning, you see.

I was out ward visiting, collecting dedications, on the evening of episode 1's broadcast, during my brief period as a Hospital Radio DJ; I remember catching a glimpse on a TV in a ward of the bit where Cy Town is drowning in a pipe of fondant. It was an intriguing excerpt, I suppose, but I wouldn't have wanted to extrapolate the whole story from just those few seconds; luckily, the recording did work. Episode 2, I watched as it was broadcast, but somehow failed to get onto tape even though I was sat in the same bloody room as the VCR. I remember reading reviews years later talking about how good was the scene between the Doctor and the two snipers, but I couldn't remember it at all. I was only over-familiar with the first and last parts. 

Reaction
The three-parter stories (two per year) were an interesting structural innovation of Sylvester McCoy's tenure in Doctor Who; faced with a reduced yearly episode count, the producer used a money stretching technique to give him four substantial serials: instead of doing a six episode story made up of a mix of studio and location work, they would do three episodes on location, and three in the studio, both as self-contained stories by different writers. It definitely got more bang for the buck; but did the stories themselves suffer? Before this point, it was rare to have a Doctor Who story with an odd number of episodes: 4s and 2s were common in the 1980s pre-Slyv, 4s and 6s before that; maybe there's a structural reason. For me, the 3-parters rarely work well. In The Happiness Patrol episode 1, for example, Ace gets angry that someone she's befriended has been killed; but she's literally exchanged four sentences with him over the course of a couple of minutes: the reaction is disproportionate, and therefore feels unearned and crudely melodramatic. Perhaps another episode of build up might have bedded in some relationships, and made this moment work better. Or perhaps it's just badly written and / or directed.

The Happiness Patrol suffers like most of the three-parters I've viewed for the blog previously (Silver Nemesis, for example, or Delta and the Bannermen) from too much going on - too many characters, too many subplots -  for any one of them to have resonance or depth. Why, when there's only three parts, was the trend to stuff in so much? What does Silas P contribute to the overall plot? Or Trevor Sigma? Or even the Kandyman, for that matter? It's a great idea for a villain, great costume, great performance, some great lines. But all of that fuel burns outside of an engine, because the character has nothing to do, and doesn't propel any part of the plot forward. He's also criminally introduced mid-episode, doing something non-threatening in a dull long shot, with no build up. This may not be wholly down to bad direction, as there were so many scenes deleted from the overrunning episodes; one of those could have been a better intro for the main villain (I couldn't muster enough enthusiasm to check the DVD). Still, they held back revealing the rubbish pipe people but not the Kandyman - they didn't have a clue what they had.

Talking of characters that don't propel the plot forward: what do the Doctor and Ace do in this story exactly? There are some little bits of business here and there, but mostly they just get captured, escape and get recaptured again. There's a big build up (including the episode 2 cliffhanger) about Ace's imminent gladiatorial turn in Happiness Patrol auditions, but then it doesn't happen. It doesn't happen! The Doctor meanwhile inspires a rebellion. Maybe. A bit. Does he, though? When exactly? We don't really see it on screen, except for an implausible bit where he persuades a Patrol squad that they can't shoot people who are smiling. Why don't they just go ahead and shoot them anyway? There are no witnesses, and the Patrol have been shown to be ruthless in previous scenes. Perhaps there are witnesses - it takes place in the forum, which we've been told it is mandatory for the populace to attend, but there's nobody in the audience (unless they were supposed to be quietly off-screen)? In the end, the dictatorship falls as it just must have been its time to do so, and all those factory workers and guards rebel on their own with no help from our heroes. It's hardly satisfying.

Sheila Hancock's barnstorming performance as Helen A, a caricature of then Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, is rightly praised, but - the nice analogy about sweets as emblems of unfettered capitalism, and the miner's strike parallels, notwithstanding - Helen A's regime isn't like Thatcher's; and, though their soundbites are very similar, she doesn't act much like Thatcher either.  The disappearances are more like Pinochet, the factories are reminiscent of Stalin's 5-year plans. Lack of focus blunts the satire. But then there's the final scene, with the Doctor confronting Helen A, and her breaking down into tears, with a crane shot pulling up just a little, the music swelling, and it all comes together, and one feels like forgiving the many sins. There are a few other moments that are similarly wonderful amongst the mess: Gilbert M and the Kandyman squabbling, the scene with the Doctor and the snipers, of course; plus, the music is outstanding - one of the best scores of the 1980s, composed by Dominic Glynn. It wouldn't normally be enough to save it, but it's just such a great concept that it doesn't seem to need to be a great narrative. No Archbishop of Canterbury is ever going to write a sermon about Silver Nemesis, after all. (Though I have to say, if one did, I would want to hear it!) 

Connectivity:
Both this story and the last have an underlying theme about shallow things being used to placate the masses, and both take this to the extreme of depicting thematic killings by mechanised creatures: death by sweets in The Happiness Patrol, death by game shows in Bad Wolf / The Parting of the Ways.

Deeper Thoughts:
The Politics of Dancing (around the schedules). The Happiness Patrol's satirical focus could easily be a prompt for me to go off on one in the Deeper Thoughts section about UK politics again, but all of Doctor Who is political. Everything is political. Moving a popular TV show that's been shown on the same night of the week for more than a decade is, in some small way, a political act. Yes: Doctor Who's 11th series since it returned in 2005, Jodie Whittaker's first run, is not going to be a Saturday night adventure, but a Sunday night drama. It's been over a week since the announcement of this (which also confirmed that the series starts on Sunday 7th October) and I'm still processing it. There were presumably howls of outrage from some quarters of online fandom about it, but - and this is becoming a regular pattern - I've not seen any signs of negativity. Maybe we're all getting more mature; or, maybe the usual suspects are all outraged out, having already exploded in recent times about the Doctor being female and the Doctor Who Magazine Time Team being too young.

How do I feel about it? Slightly, just slightly, mentally dislocated. It is another bit of evidence to add to the accumulated weight that suggests that the new production team is making a hell of effort to do things differently, and make this a true relaunch: new Doctor, new gender, new number and length of episodes, new showrunner, all new commissioned writers, all new directors, new house composer, new logo, etc. etc. Now, a new day of the week to view it on. There is no precedent for a new series of Who to change so many things from the previous year, all in one go. When Steven Moffat took over in 2010, a lot of things changed, but the music and some of the writers at least provided continuity. And it was still on Saturday. Going back further, the closest analogue might be when John Nathan Turner took over, and revamped almost everything. It was still on Saturday, though, but it moved from that traditional slot the following year. To be presented with something so unprecedented now is refreshing, but ever so slightly scary.

Why scary? Well, that move in 1982, from the traditional Saturday slot where Doctor Who had resided for eighteen years to two early evening weeknight slots per week, is seen by some as the point where it all started to go wrong, the beginning of the end. After that, Doctor Who bounced around the schedules without a proper home: different weeknights for a couple of years, back to Saturday for a couple more, then finally the last death rattle before cancellation when the show was back on weeknights but opposite ITV's highest-rating programme at the time, Coronation Street. It was as if the schedulers didn't know what to do with it, couldn't understand why people were watching, and were a little bit ashamed of the show.

Any comparison of that situation to what's happening now is probably ridiculous, but we don't like change, we long-term fans, and we worry still that any day now, the BBC could decide to just stop making the show. It's understandable, as the last four or five years the show was on in the 1980s, that's how it felt, that's how it was - every series could have been the last. It's not the only political shadow that fell during the 1980s that is still potentially affecting my generation's feelings and behaviour now, it was a turbulent but never boring time to be young. The good news is I very much  doubt that's going to happen this year or any time soon: every little hint and glimpse we're being given - the latest being the wonderful 'glass ceiling' teaser - has been confident and successful. Roll on Sunday the 7th...

In Summary:
Conceptually, it makes me happy; but the actual story brings on mostly frowns.

Sunday, 30 August 2015

Silver Nemesis


Chapter The Eleventh, wherein turn up perpetual silver medal winning baddies, the Cybermen.

Plot:
Various comic-book characters - Nazis,a 17th Century black magic-practising noblewoman, shiny cyborgs, Dr. Who and his sassy teenage sidekick, Ace - fight over this week's Timelord superweapon MacGuffin. Everyone but The Doctor and Ace and the noblewoman's friendly henchman (who only drank the blood of one murdered person, so he's okay) get blown up or killed. Throughout, lots of people talk heavy-handedly about the mystery of the Doctor, rather like children who know what your birthday present is, and are desperate to tell you before you open it.

Context:
Off work for summer hols, I sat down to watch the DVD with the whole family. Jealous at middle-child (boy, now 6) getting to occasionally derail the random selection of stories, my eldest child (boy, now 9) insisted on choosing this story as it's one of his favourites. Luckily, it still fits my plan to start with one story from each Doctor. My Better Half, by the way, lasted until halfway through the title sequence of episode one; spotting the DVD box, she said something along the lines of "Not this old toss, I'm off" and was not seen again.

First-time round:
I watched on its initial BBC1 broadcast in 1988, when I had just started sixth-form college. I have a vague memory that I missed episode 2 completely, meaning I did not see at the time some of the more infamous scenes (anything to do with the skinheads, for example). I still thought it was rubbish, mind. A few weeks later, during the broadcast of the subsequent story, a friend of my sister's, Nadia, was round our house. I quite fancied her, and somehow managed to find myself chatting alone with her, when she - she! - brought up the topic of Doctor Who. She mentioned that she'd liked the recent show with the Cybermen, and I suavely but coolly said "Jesus! Did you? You're wrong - it was utter shit". As I closed off for ever what might have been a different path of my life, I could not help but think of the words of T. S. Eliot: "Down the passage which we did not take, towards the door we never opened". Eliot never mentioned vomiting all over the passage and door for good measure, but - you know - I'm thorough.

A lot of the location work was done in places around my then home town of Worthing. The cast stayed in a Worthing seafront hotel, where my schoolfriend Dominic was working in the Summer of 1988 after we'd done our GCSEs. He reported back on important topics like how Sophie Aldred was much better looking than her tomboy appearance in Dragonfire made out, but he thought she had a boyfriend.

Much later, I was best man to my friend Phil when he got married in St. Mary's House in Bramber, the location used for Lady Peinforte's home. I was banned from making any reference to this in my speech.

Reaction:

Slvester McCoy and Sophie Aldred, as the Doctor and Ace, are one of those TARDIS teams that just clicked instantly with a wonderful on-screen chemistry, and their presence lifts any material. The best parts of Silver Nemesis are the two of them having fun, wandering around WindsorArudel in the bright November sunshine, listening to jazz, jumping into the river for a lark. The only problem is this keeps getting interrupted by bits of the plot taking itself too seriously, or not taking itself seriously enough. And it's a stretch to use the word 'plot', as what happens is so very, very slight: people arrive, they wander around a bit, then everything gets blown up. The End.

There's not much point criticising individual scenes as the whole thing is padding; I did, after all, miss the whole middle episode without having any difficulty keeping up. What's amazing is that there were reels and reels of deleted scenes, as the episodes all went over-length. Enough, it turned out, to do a special edition of the story on VHS some years later. Most of it is just more upholstery, but there is also a sequence cut where some parties join forces then double-cross each other - it might have formed some actual story development, had it been written, directed or performed well. It sadly wasn't.

Silver Nemesis is my least favourite McCoy (yes, I honestly enjoy Time and The Rani more). The Cybermen are very badly used and don't look quite right. In line with this being the story set around and celebrating the 25th anniversary of Doctor Who's start date, they have been buffed to a shine, but they were never ever gleaming silver before, so it doesn't really connect and they look stupid. And there's no excuse for their suddenly having bulbous sausage fingers by the incorporation of cricket gloves into the costume.

But, I'm remaining upbeat, in something of the spirit of the middle years of the Doctor Who DVD range, where they were deliberately releasing less well-regarded stories, to save the good stuff for later. It can only get better from now on.

Connectivity:
Both this and The Ultimate Foe are about various larger-than-life characters trying to get hold of Timelord stuff, and - for the third story in a row - it's all too tied up in the show's ongoing mythology for its own good.
 
Deeper Thoughts:
What secrets would Lady Peinforte have spilled exactly? By coincidence, a lot of the stories I've watched for the blog so far have contained large quantities of continuity / mythology / ongoing plot, whatever you want to call the stuff. It's luck of the draw, as Doctor Who wasn't always like this; but, perhaps inevitably when watching in any old order, the more stand-alone stories are winning it thus far. Ultimate Foe and Armageddon Outahere are the closing sections of year-long stories, Flatline and Let's Kill Hitler suffer to lesser or greater degrees from having to stuff in lots of arc bits. The TV Movie and Arc of Infinity overestimate their viewers' interest in Gallifreyan gear and gadgetry.

Silver Nemesis, although indulging in a bit of nostalgia as it's an anniversary show, is trying for something different: to move Doctor Who into a new phase. Unfortunately, the writer Kevin Clarke, following what was later dubbed the Masterplan of script editor Andrew Cartmel, attempts to do this by creating a new backstory for the Doctor, and then dropping hints about it. This is bound not to work in a long-running series, particularly one that's been going for a quarter century: oh, did I not mention all this mysterious stuff about me any time in the last 25 years? Sorry, it's just never come up in all that time, but in the last couple of weeks people can't stop banging on about it. Strange, I know.

No, it was never going to convince. They've anyway already moved things on and created mystery within the Doctor's character. When the actor changes, it's a blank slate, and a perfect organic point to create a little mystery: what is this guy going to be like? Since his first year in the role, McCoy along with the writers is flagging up the darker manipulative side of his Pierrot-like persona. In Silver Nemesis, when alone with the statue, he says he can't yet let it have its freedom as "Things are still imperfect". That's just enough, and everything else could never be that restrained or subtle. The script even acknowledges this, when the cybermen are not interested in the slightest in whatever Peinforte has to divulge. This is just as well, as knowing now the full details of the Cartmel Masterplan, the scene would have run like this:

PEINFORTE: I shall tell them of Gallifrey, tell them of the old time, the time of chaos.

DOCTOR: Be my guest.

PEINFORTE: Well, Cyberleader, get this: the Doctor is really The Other, who - with Rassilon and Omega - formed a trio of ancient Time lord guys long ago on Gallifrey who were obsessed with building superweapons and stuff. And his house is called Lungbarrow, he's got loads of odd cousins, and he was born in a loom.

[Cyberleader stands with hands on hips, coughs; a tumbleweed goes by.]

CYBERLEADER: Ok, well... thanks, I guess. But we're still going to blow some shit up with your statue.


In Summary:
Dull, not shiny, and as padded as a cricket glove.