Showing posts with label season 20. Show all posts
Showing posts with label season 20. Show all posts

Monday, 29 May 2023

Enlightenment

Chapter the 266th, in which there's a chase during a race in space to a place of utmost grace. And the video picture is interlaced... (that's enough - Ed).


Plot:
The Doctor's new travelling companion Turlough has done a deal with the Black Guardian, agreeing to kill the Doctor, but can't go through with it. The White Guardian appears in the TARDIS, draining its power and dimming the lights to project himself, warning the Time Lord of impending danger: someone must be prevented from winning a race. The TARDIS arrives below decks in what appears to be an Edwardian racing yacht, but it's really a space ship with sails to catch solar winds. Many vessels styled after different Earth historical periods are in competition for the ultimate prize: Enlightenment. The officers of each are Eternals, beings that live outside time and cannot ever die, who use humans (or Ephemerals as they call them) for entertainment, and have brought groups of sailors from various times to crew their ships. The TARDIS team are on the Shadow, captained by the mysterious Striker; First Mate Marriner takes a shine to Tegan. The Black Guardian telepathically taunts Turlough that he is abandoning him to a fate of perpetual confinement on the ship, so Turlough jumps overboard. He is picked up by the Buccaneer, a pirate ship captained by the Eternal Captain Wrack. Wrack appears to be destroying other ships to gain advantage, by harnessing the Black Guardian's powers and focusing them on jewels she has tricked the other Captains into receiving as a gift. Striker is too wily to accept anything from her, though, so - at a party on the Buccaneer that everyone is invited to - Wrack hypnotises Tegan, and hides a jewel in the tiara she's wearing.

The others return to the Shadow without Turlough, who's taking his chances with Wrack. The Doctor manages to get the jewel overboard before it destroys the ship. Wrack has all the other Captains walk the plank, so the race is between the Shadow and the Buccaneer. The wind dies and the Shadow is becalmed, but the Buccaneer's sails are better. The Doctor goes back in the TARDIS to help Turlough, and from the Shadow Tegan sees two people ejected from the pirate ship. It is Captain Wrack and her First Mate Mansell that have been thrown overboard, though, and the Doctor and Turlough bring the Buccaneer over the finishing line. The Black and White Guardians are waiting for them. Striker, Marriner and Tegan come over to congratulate the winners. The Guardians send the Eternals back to their own dimension and offer Enlightenment to the Doctor, but he turns it down as not something he - or anyone else - is ready for. Turlough is offered part of Enlightenment, but the Black Guardian reminds him that he still owes a debt of the Doctor's life. Turlough has to choose, and gives the Black Guardian the portion of Enlightenment, which appears to burn the Black Guardian up. The Doctor explains that Enlightenment wasn't the glowing diamond thing they were presented with but was actually the friends they made along the way, or something.


Context:
Blogging this story, I have completed the 20th anniversary season of Doctor Who from 1983, 40 years on during the 60th anniversary year for the show. It's a shame that the - long rumoured - Blu-ray box set of this run has not been announced (at least at time of writing); I have a feeling it won't be too long before it comes out, and Enlightenment could well have been the story chosen for a BFI screening to tie-in. It would have been nice, assuming I would have been able to get a ticket, to cover that as part of any blog post. Unfortunately, the Blu-ray release schedule can't keep pace with my blogging frequency. Season 20 is the tenth now completed for the blog (following seasons 3, 8, 14, 15, 17, 23 and 25, and new series 6 and 13). If I keep up my three posts a month average, it's going to become more and more common to close these gaps, until I catch up with currently broadcast stories (some time in 2024, depending on when Ncuti Gatwa's first season airs). Anyway, I watched from the DVD as the best quality version available, an episode a night across a few days in May 2023. I was accompanied by the Better Half, who had no memory of watching these episodes since she first saw them 40 years ago. She expressed sororal admiration at Janet Fielding's ability to keep a boob tube up ("'Cos that's a hard thing to do if you haven't got much of a bust"), and moaned a lot about Peter Davison's hair being too long. She is a big All Creatures Great and Small fan (both original and the new Channel 5 version) and was moaning that Tristan's hair was too long in the 1983 ACGAS Christmas Special, which I told her was probably because Davison appeared in that between Doctor Who seasons and therefore couldn't get it cut. She has another thing to blame Doctor Who for now.   

First Time Round:
I watched this when it first went out in early March 1983, when I was just a callow schoolboy. I can only remember one thing about that first watch, and - sorry to raise the ick factor - but it was my going through another stage of my pre-pubescent sexual awakening upon watching Janet Fielding in her Edwardian decolletage be hypnotised by Lynda Baron as Captain Wrack. Enlightenment has more mature emotional and psychosexual subtexts than the average Doctor Who story, and the 10-year old me definitely caught something of that at some level of my psyche / hormones. Curiously, it wasn't so rare for stories shown around this time featuring Janet Fielding; earlier in the season was Snakedance, the sequel to the previous year's Kinda (watching which started the aforementioned pre-pubescent sexual awakening in the first place).


Reaction:
Doctor Who Magazine has structured its 60th anniversary poll of all broadcast stories differently to previous polls it has run over the years, perhaps to avoid upsetting Colin Baker again (see the Deeper Thoughts section of this early blog post for more details). This means that each Doctor will have their top three most voted for stories go into another poll, through which the overall final order of that second round subset will be chosen. There's still a chance that a Colin Baker story could come last of those, of course, but it won't be The Twin Dilemma this time at least (though that one did come last out of Colin's stories, as it always does, as confirmed in the most recent DWM at time of writing). As usual, I am avoiding any pressure of picking my top three by not entering the poll at all; if I were choosing, though, I'd coincidentally probably pick the last three I had left to blog at this point, with Kinda and The Caves of Androzani as well as Enlightenment getting my top marks. Randomness has saved my best for last, but my taste does not quite accord with everyone else's. Caves is a shoo-in, it's been in the top five of all Who stories in every one of the polls run to date, including nabbing the coveted number one spot in 2009. It was Peter Davison's top story in the first round of this latest poll as expected. My other two, though, didn't make it to the final. More action-oriented stories Earthshock and The Five Doctors - predictably - completed the top three instead (this is consistent with all the previous polls over the years). The more thoughtful, lyrical stories like Enlightenment are lower down, even though, in my humble, they are the ones that Doctor Who, and in particular this period of the show, do most well.


Every aspect of Enlightenment is effective at worst, superlative at best. From the first scene, one aspect is clearly better than normal, particularly for this period of the show, and that's the lighting. Watching the atmospheric TARDIS scenes at the beginning makes one wonder (as Davison himself says on one of the DVD extras) why they can't light the set like that every time. It's not just there, though; the scenes in the Eternals' ships are lit well in Television Centre, as are the top deck scenes filmed at Ealing. The nature of the race plot, involving groups of Eternals cosplaying from various periods of Earth history, means various creatives on the crew can utilise their skill and the stored resources of the BBC to produce great costumes and sets. This is particularly evident in the party scenes in part three that bring all the various ships' inhabitants together. The spacesuits, reminiscent of those in 2001 A Space Odyssey, are good too, it's not just the period stuff that's done well. Make-up and hair is also top class (Tegan does look stunning in her Edwardian party outfit and wig). Sailing craft in space is a big ask of model-work, but again the people behind the scenes come through. The reveal at the end of part one cliffhanger of multiple vessels hanging in space is a triumph of incongruous imagination, and one of the best in the series' history. Effects work throughout is strong, with only a couple of exceptions (but every Doctor Who story has some flaws, and here they are tiny); sound design and music are exquisite (more on the music in the Deeper Thoughts section below).


None of this would work without a good script and good performances. Enlightenment automatically has potential for a unique viewpoint as it is both written by a woman, and directed by a (different) woman. This would be the only time in the 26 years of the classic series such a thing happened, and it's only happened a couple of times since, and those very recently. Neither of those females are relying on any novelty, though, both work incredibly hard and deliver the goods. Director Fiona Cumming is a perfect match for this more lyrical story (having helmed stories like Castrovalva and Snakedance before this). She puts together one of the best ensemble casts Who has had, even though she had to react to some last minute changes when shooting dates were altered. I think that was a piece of luck; as good as Peter Sallis, originally cast as Striker, would have no doubt been, the series would have been deprived of what I think is one of the best performances of the classic era, Keith Barron's restrained but intense turn as the captain of the Shadow. At the time, I knew him only as a comic actor from a sit-com, so I was blown away, and am every time I watch this story again. Even something like raising a glass of wine to his lips is imbued with suppressed, inscrutable energy. The other recast role was Leee John, at the time known only as a pop singer in the band Imagination, as the baddie's sidekick Mansell. The performances of him and Lynda Baron - as pirate queen Wrack - come in for criticism, but I think they are both pitched perfectly. They are both playing characters who are playing characters, and gleefully.


The regulars all get served well. Davison gets a lot of good scenes facing off against the amoral Striker in righteous dudgeon, with the dialogue between them crackling ("Living minds are contaminated with crude emotions, organic, irrational, creative, entertaining" ... "A Lord of Time - are there lords in such a small domain?" etc. etc.) This is probably Turlough's best material, still struggling between good and bad choices, up to the end when he sits between a good and bad angel, almost literally, and finally decides which side he's on. Even a minor subplot like his betrayal of Tony Caunter's teetotal sailor Jackson is written and performed seriously, just one of many magical moments with which the story is blessed. The scene when Mark Strickson is thrown to the floor in front of Baron's Wrack for the first time, gets to his knees and looks up, with Cumming choosing low and high POV shots, is probably as close as Doctor Who could go to highlighting a sub-dom sexual subtext - it's almost like something out of a Frankie Goes to Hollywood video. The love subplot between Christopher Brown's Marriner and Tegan is sensitively handled but emotionally rich, and gives Janet Fielding her best scenes in any show that's not a Mara story. Barbara Clegg's complex and layered scripts contain many such resonances. The Eternals using the Ephemerals could be seen as a comment on gender (Marriner's unwanted advances ultimately being rejected by Tegan as he's only interested in himself) or class (the rich officer class exploiting the toil of those below decks to make them rich) or just as an interesting science-fiction concept in and of themselves.


I've barely scratched the surface of all the wonderful elements in this story. Unlike Earthshock or The Five Doctors, conflict is mostly at an interpersonal level; there's not much running around and zapping, and any monstrousness is not overt. Fans may have been disappointed that the big confrontation between the Black and White Guardians (something teased for five years but not seen on screen before Enlightenment) comes down to two men sitting on chairs, while the action is all internal, one person's choice. I think this is perfect, though, and much more effective than any attempt at pyrotechnics might have been. There's wonderful creepiness too, in scenes of space-suited Edwardian sailors queueing up for grog, or Marriner's hands and face appearing on the TARDIS scanner screen as he climbs up the outside of the TARDIS and then looks inside, sensing Tegan for the first time, with a sick smile on his face. Maybe this isn't traditional enough for some fans, but it obviously speaks to a good few including me: the story came fifth in the recent poll (Kinda was fourth); not too shabby.

Connectivity:
Both Enlightenment and The Idiot's Lantern feature female villains beginning with W (Wrack and Wire, The) and references to sailors (Rose's Mum's ex with incorrect flag advice in the Tennant story and a full ship's complement in Enlightenment). 

Deeper Thoughts:
Malcolm Clarke and the Musical Movements. The late, great Barry Letts was someone with the best claim to being a Doctor Who expert in its classic era, having performed pretty much every key role (directing before and after his time as producer, writing stories during that time and after, and finally returning to briefly be the executive producer at the beginning of the 1980s, a couple of years before Enlightenment was made). He also lived long enough to see the programme come back (indeed, was an honoured guest at the 2005 press screening of relaunch episode Rose) and share his wisdom in many interviews for DVD range releases. I barely have ever had the temerity to disagree with him on any view about the programme, as he's almost certainly going to turn out to be right. There have been a couple of times, though, that I've been convinced that he's wrong. One of these is in his opinions about the incidental music for The Sea Devils by Malcolm Clarke. At the time that music was first recorded, Barry Letts decided he didn't like it, and remained vocal about this thereafter. Having just finished working through all the extras from the Blu-ray box set of the season containing The Sea Devils, I heard him reiterate that he hated it on camera in a making-of documentary, and I heard him reiterate that he hated it on audio during commentaries. As ever, I heard all this thinking "How can he say this, when The Sea Devils has the best score of any classic Who story?!' It's innovative, exciting and in keeping with the action - Clarke somehow makes the electronically produced noises he creates supremely nautical.


While criticising The Sea Devils music, Letts praises Tristram Cary's just as experimental (but a bit more tasteful and therefore boring) score for the following story The Mutants. I hope this was Letts' honest reaction to the material and not him being blinded by status. Cary was a famous composer, but Letts sniffily refers to Clarke at one point essentially as a sound designer for the Radiophonic Workshop with ideas above his station. Of course, most of those working at the Workshop were composers too, and Clarke went on to score a good few Doctor Who stories, including Enlightenment. The cue used for the party sequences on Wrack's ship, for example, is beautiful, and a hell of an earworm. I defy anyone to say it's not the work of a real composer. His 1980s work was less divisive than his first score for the series, but it's fair to say that it was still quite divisive. Some might feel that there's not much point in creating something if it's not challenging; others might think that incidental music isn't the place for anything that stands out too much. I am sympathetic with the latter view, but this is Doctor Who we're talking about. It has always innovated in every aspect, particularly sonically, from the very first moments of the very first episode, and the Radiophonic Workshop was always a big part of that. Special sound was always within their remit, and even without their direct involvement the incidentals were often electronic and experimental (like Cary's score for the second ever story, The Daleks).


Generally, there are phases in the music used for periods of Doctor Who's life, where the sound is distinctive of that era. The 1960s splits into three for me, but as more experimentation was going on from one story to the next, it is not so clearly delineated. At the start of the show's life there was a tendency towards using new original scores, anywhere on the axis between traditional and experimental. Towards the end of the William Hartnell period, stock music becomes more prevalent, with clever use of repeating motifs (like the Space Adventure track that underscored the early stories of the Cybermen, becoming their de facto theme tune). Finally, as the 1960s progressed towards the end of Patrick Troughton's time in the title role, there's a period where the phenomenon of no music at all was tried. Maybe budgeting was more challenging, but even without music, there's usually something interesting to hear. Brian Hodgson's background soundscapes for stories like The Krotons can lay claim to be the Workshop's first incidentals, a few years before Malcolm Clarke's undersea opus. Into the 1970s, there's another brief period of experimentation, including The Sea Devils, before it rapidly becomes standard for stories to have traditional scores, almost always composed by Dudley Simpson. This is how things stayed for the rest of the decade. Producer for the 1980s John Nathan-Turner went a different way, giving Simpson the push, and engaging composers wholesale from the Workshop.


Clarke scored six stories in this period, alongside other composers like Peter Howell, Paddy Kingsland, Roger Limb, and others. He contributes the final workshop Doctor Who score in 1986, when the final classic series musical movement is already underway. Individual freelance composers working on their own synthesisers are responsible for the music of the final four years of classic Who, technology having caught up to make this possible. In the 21st century, there's been much less movement. Apart from Segun Akinola's scoring of Jodie Whittaker's episodes, every story's music has been written by one person, Murray Gold. The level of experimentation has only been whatever Gold brought to each new score. Though he's challenged himself to keep things fresh, it does seem a shame that Gold is now coming back, seemingly for every episode henceforth. It might have been nicer to try something new, and it does seem a bit backward looking. Still, the Russell T Davies writing the stories will be a different man than the one that wrote his last Who story in 2009; so, perhaps we'll see an all-new Gold to the one that last produced music for the show in 2017. Time will tell, as it always does. 

In Summary:
It's better than Earthshock and The Five Doctors put together; so there!

Saturday, 31 October 2020

Snakedance

 

Chapter The 169th, which features snakes on an astral plane.


Plot:

Tegan is having a recurring nightmare, evidence that the Mara creature is still living in her subconscious mind. The Mara takes brief control and sets the TARDIS destination coordinates to arrive at Manussa, its home world. Celebrations are ongoing as it is the 500th anniversary of the destruction of the Mara by someone who went on to found 'the federation'. This federation doesn't seem to be the Star Trek one, nor the Blake's 7 one, including as it does an inherited power structure, with the current federator being a descendent of that founder. His wife Tanha and son Lon are in town for the closing ceremony of the celebrations. The Doctor and Nyssa lose Tegan who falls more and more under the Mara's control. Investigating, the Doctor finds out that there is a legend of the return of the Mara, being brought back through a dream, which suggests that Tegan will make that legend come true. He tries to persuade people of this, including Ambril, the director of the Mara research institute, but everyone thinks he's a ranting conspiracy freak.


Tegan meets with Lon, and the Mara takes him over too. Lon plays on Ambril's greed to persuade him to include the great crystal in the imminent ceremony, something that's strictly forbidden. The crystal, the great mind's eye, was built by the advanced civilisation that previously inhabited the planet, and which was destroyed and lost during the Mara's reign. It can turn thoughts into energy and matter, and it was this that created the Mara in the first place, when it absorbed all the negative energy of the populace. The Doctor, helped by Nyssa and Ambril's assistant Chela, locate the previous director, Dojjen, who has gone to live in the wilds of the planet with a tribe called the Snake Dancers. The rituals of this tribe involve meditation while under the influence of a snake's poisonous bite, as mental preparation for the Mara's return. Dojjen gives the Doctor the clue to how to defeat the Mara, finding the 'still point' in himself. At the ceremony, Lon puts the crystal back in its socket in a cave, and the Mara starts to become a corporeal reality again. The Doctor and friends arrive as everyone is falling under the Mara's control, but the Doctor resists, and this resistance destroys the Mara.



Context:

As is becoming the current style when viewing classic series multi-part stories, this was watched from the DVD, one episode at a time, spread out over a week or so. This seems to go down better with those accompanying me on the watch (the three children, boys aged 14 and 11, girl aged 8) than doing it all in one go. The Better Half is still not partaking, which is a shame in this instance, as I know she watched and was scared by a moment in this story (the dead snake vomiting pink goo) as a nipper; she watched it with me a long time ago, though, probably when the DVD first came out, and discovered that it was no longer scary to her at all. The children didn't seem scared by anything in the story either, though the youngest thought that some of the early scenes were creepy. The eldest kept asking why one of the main characters was named after a car, until I clarified that it's Nyssa not Nissan.


First time round:

I first watched this story on its debut BBC1 broadcast in January 1983. I'd very much enjoyed the story Kinda the previous year, for which Snakedance was the sequel, so was very excited by another story featuring the Mara. I think, despite the giveaway in the title, that I came to the story unaware that it included said psychogenic python, or mental mamba. I could have been spoilered, though as by this time I was regularly buying and reading Doctor Who Magazine. I remember reading an article on Tegan and Nyssa's new frocks around the time of watching this story, but I don't remember it giving away any details of the plot. On the subject of magazines, as I mentioned in my post about the preceding story of the season Arc of Infinity (the very first story covered by this blog), my family only got the Radio Times at Christmas, so I normally would not have seen the listings for Snakedance. I did, though, see the first episode's write-up while round at a friend's house whose folks took the magazine throughout the whole year. I was intrigued by the odd story title WhoSnakedance, until I realised that the words had just been printed too close together.



Reaction:

The Doctor Who Discontinuity Guide, one of my favourite publications about classic Who, says of Snakedance that it is "Not quite as gorgeous as 'Kinda', since it almost tries to be a normal Doctor Who". I have to take exception to this. Both the Mara stories, writer Christopher Bailey's only contributions to Doctor Who, are great, and both stand out as attempting to transcend the usual format of the show. Of the two, though, I think Snakedance breaks the mould more. Kinda has a few action scenes, some of which involve the moving robot armour box thingy, the TSS, which is very in-keeping with the action-adventure style brought in by Eric Saward as script editor, working with John Nathan-Turner as producer. Bailey, having had trouble making Kinda's scripts work in the editing process, has now learnt the formula, and this helps him subvert it more effectively. He delivers something superficially more acceptable, but which is fundamentally different from the stories around it. Snakedance has barely more than a couple of scuffles with guards, which Bailey implies on Snakedance DVD's Making-of documentary were bits that Saward insisted he add. The remainder of the action of the story takes place entirely within the minds of the key characters.


Why doesn't this produce something static and dull? First, those mental battles are visualised with some striking imagery and special sound. This is sometimes big stuff, like the repeated images of snakes or snake skulls, but the story succeeds in the more subtle stuff too. For example, the intermittent dialogue-free cutaways to the at first unnamed shaman, who we gradually realise is Dojjen, waiting in the barren hills, wild-looking but silent and still. These are jarring, unexplained and deliberately disrupting to the texture as they are filmed rather than on video, though still in a studio. Magic. For any Who that is studio-bound without location filming there is a risk that it will feel stagey, but here that's embraced. Manussa is a bit threadbare, having reduced its rich history down to a tawdry sideshow, so the less realistic and more theatrical feel (of "shoddy little booths" as Lon has it in the script) is fitting. The production has learnt lessons from Kinda, and nothing is as unconvincing as the final snake manifestation in that story; the various depictions are still not perfect, but as good as could be expected of the skills and technology available at the time, with clever use of real snakes towards the end, and the final large rearing snake model convincing well.



The second factor keeping up the energy in Snakedance is the world-beating world-building. The story of Snakedance is essentially the backstory of Kinda, explaining how the Mara came to be. Exposition is so cleverly distributed through the narrative, as the Doctor uncovers the history, and its played with such conviction, that it never feels that way. An example of this is the quiet, but nonetheless devastating moment when Nyssa and the Doctor realise that the blue Manussan crystals are man-made, and what this implies. The Mara was not an invading evil from another world or reality. It's something that the people created themselves, the embodiment of their darkest desires. This scene is played out while the two TARDIS travellers are imprisoned in a cell, another superficially archetypal Doctor Who moment; but, instead of being padding or allowing for exciting escape attempts, it instead is just an opportunity to allow them to think and to talk. Bailey is smuggling in the mystical in these more ordinary clothes. Beyond the moments driving the narrative, he also litters his story with brief moments highlighting the character of this world, making it real: the six faces of delusion, the Surprise, the Punch and Judy show with a snake in place of a crocodile, and many more.

 

The characters all form part of this tapestry of forgotten tradition too. Each one of the local characters we meet - with the exception of the enlightened Dojjen - has lost track of what's important about the history they are nominally celebrating, and all for different reasons. Ambril intellectualises away any possibility that the civilisations before could have been wiser than him, convinced of his superiority; Lon is too indulged and bored to consider anything more important than his own pleasure; Tanha is blinded by her aristocratic life, and a bit too easily led by her spoilt son, to listen to anyone else; Dugdale just wants money, and the fortune teller just wants to please her audience. Even Chela, a character with more curiosity than the rest of them put together, is still too meek to challenge his boss. At the end of the story - a rare one for Doctor Who in which everybody lives - you get the feeling that everyone's going to feel very embarrassed now that they've woken from the Mara's spell. Without the intervention of the Doctor, they would have turned their world to hell not by being evil, but just by being a bit inept. Somehow, that's even more devastating. 



The director Fiona Cumming is a perfect match for a more mystical and lyrical script, and she gets great performances out of everyone. None of these is quite as flashy as the performances of Kinda, but they are just as high quality. Particular praise should go to Martin Clunes as Lon, in one of his earliest roles in a long TV career. He often ended up represented by Snakedance in those "Before They Were Famous"-style clip compilations, for wearing dodgy 80s clobber and eye make-up. It's terribly unfair, as he does everything that could be expected of him and more, nailing the part and having great chemistry with Colette O'Neil as his mother. She in turn is doing a right-royal job of channeling a certain UK family of inherited influence, but it goes beyond an impression and allows for some subtle moments. There is just a flash of wistful regret as she talks about her absent husband that speaks volumes about the life she's had after marrying into this life, and instantly explains her character, and her indulgence of her son. The regular cast shouldn't be forgotten either; Janet Fielding is having a ball playing both a scared Tegan, and the commanding Mara, often switching between the two in a single scene. Peter Davison too gives a great performance; his Doctor is ineffectual here only because of the granite-like stubbornness of everyone's imagination on Manussa; he plays off that with an increasing desperation which powers the narrative to the end.  

  

Connectivity: 

Snakedance and Image of the Fendahl have a very similar structure: an ancient evil, which had previously been thought destroyed but was merely dormant, influences people unconsciously to help recreate itself. It gains power through a glowing object (skull, crystal) takes over and physically alters a woman, then starts to take over more people, who cannot look away. Similarly,the evil's defeated in both instances as at least one person is able to resist, leaving it incomplete. In both stories, age-old legends are thought to be codified warnings or tips for defeating the evil.



Deeper Thoughts:

A big Bailey-Who! The speed that the world wide web and social media allows for the dissemination of false information is rightly a current concern, but the times before the web had their share of rumours, myths and hoaxes too. Doctor Who was particularly beset in those days. In fact, because it has since attracted a vast band of online know-it-alls who've investigated the series in every detail over the years, a hoax would be quickly quashed now; but, when the series was less well researched, and when information travelled at a much slower rate around the globe, certain stories did endure. One such tale was created when Doctor Who's organised fandom and tie-in journalism (both of which being in their relative infancy at the time) lost track of Christopher Bailey. After the two Mara stories, he was commissioned for Doctor Who a couple more times in 1982 and 83, but both stories did not progress to production. After that, Bailey "disappeared" for a couple of decades, until his "elusive" self was tracked down by Benjamin Cook of Doctor Who Magazine, and interviewed for a feature published in 2002. In truth, he hadn't disappeared and wasn't being elusive, he was just getting on with his life, and hadn't factored his couple of Who scripts as being that important in the scheme of things.



The interview was a great piece of work, and Cook was rightly congratulated for it at the time. It revealed not an antipathy for the show from one of its cleverest contributors, but an unaggressive perspective of its relative unimportance, intelligently presented without prejudice. It was refreshing, but possibly made for hard reading amongst a readership that set a great deal more store by the show than Bailey did. The interview had a positive impact, though, on Robert Shearman, Doctor Who fan and writer. Shortly before he was commissioned to write Dalek, the 2005 episode of the relaunched show, he wrote an audio play loosely inspired by Bailey and Cook's interactions. It's well worth a listen. Shearman has gone on record of his admiration of Bailey as a writer, and said that Snakedance is his favourite Doctor Who story. The imaginative breadth of all his work, for Who and elsewhere, is at least partially inspired by Bailey's scripts for Doctor Who, and the play - called Deadline, and starring Derek Jacobi - is a nice celebration of that. It takes place in a counterfactual universe where the TV show Doctor Who did not develop in the same way, and in which there is an official Juliet Bravo Magazine. But even Shearman's big brain could not have scripted the story that arose between Bailey's last contribution and Cook's interview in 2002. According to that rumour, Christopher Bailey didn't exist at all.


The story was that the two Mara stories had been written under a pseudonym by none other than saucy-cerebral rock chanteuse Kate Bush. How such rumours get started is beyond me; the evidence for the prosecution seemed to boil down to the same initials (Catherine Bush = Christopher Bailey) and that Bush's work had included the odd trippy element, as do Kinda and Snakedance. With the greater access one now has to information, as I mentioned earlier, it's easy to look back and see that Bush was recording and then promoting her very first solely self-produced album during the period of 1980 to 1982, when the work on the scripts for both Mara stories was done. It does seem unlikely that she would have squeezed in lots of meetings at the BBC with Eric Saward and the writing of multiple drafts of two screenplays as well. Additionally, Christopher Bailey was interviewed for and featured in a Doctor Who book - The Unfolding Text - around the time of Kinda's production. Did the authors talk with Kate Bush and just forget to mention it? Okay, it might have been a bit more difficult to know these points prior to the internet age, but it easily would have been possible to know one other thing that would surely have made the whole rumour seem implausible: Kate Bush has never before nor since the period in question showed any tendency toward TV screenwriting. Did this not occur to anyone?



It's not the most preposterous rumour in Doctor Who's history (that would the theory that Harold Pinter temporarily put aside his stellar writing career to take on a minor acting role for six weeks in a Patrick Troughton story), but it's up there. I suppose it's apt in one way; Christopher Bailey's scripts heavily feature the importance of myth and legend; it's fitting that they gave rise to a myth, however silly, of their own.


In Summary:

Magnificent, mould-breaking, truly Mara-llous! 

Saturday, 29 February 2020

The Five Doctors

Chapter The 148th, where Tom Baker is missing but probably still in the pub.

Plot:
Every Doctor to date, and whichever companions were available, work-permitting, are gathered up by a Time Scoop operated by a mysterious person unknown on Gallifrey. The fourth Doctor (scarf, bohemian, curly hair) and Romana are caught in the time vortex, but everyone else is brought, along with Cybermen and a Dalek and some other baddies, to the death zone, an arena used for gladiatorial-style games in Gallifrey's less enlightened past. The use of the scoop causes an energy drain, so the high council of Time Lords send for the Doctor; but, finding that his time traces converge in the zone, they send the Master in to save him. The fifth Doctor (cricket, celery, blonde hair) escapes the zone and investigates who the traitor on Gallifrey might be, and finds out that it is President Borusa. The three remaining Doctors (grumpy one, flautist, dandy) separately battle against all the obstacles, and converge on the Dark Tower at the centre of the zone, where Time Lord legend Rassilon is rumoured to still be alive and handing out immortality as a prize for passing the tests. Borusa arrives with the fifth Doctor, and - against the protestations of his other selves - the first Doctor tells Rassilon to give Borusa the immortality he seeks. But it's a trap, and Borusa lives forever turned into a statue. The Time Lords want the Doctor to take over as president but he instead chooses to go on the run from his own people, in a rackety old TARDIS; that's how it all started, don't you know.

Context:
Accompanied by all the family (Better Half and three children - boys of 13 and 10, girl of 7), I watched this one Sunday evening, from the DVD. We watched the original version as transmitted in November 1983, Doctor Who's 20th anniversary. I kept the title a secret before I pressed play, and was greeted by a chorus of jeers that we were watching "an old black-and-white one", this being in reaction to the William Hartnell clip used as a pre-credits sequence. I'd love to say that the jeers turned to happy astonishment as soon as the 1980s Peter Davison titles sequence kicked in, but they were in a rowdy and mischievous mood throughout.

First time round:
This was a big, big deal at the time - an absolute event - and was trailed long before it aired in various ways. I must have known it was coming from Doctor Who Magazine, I suppose, and I remember that was months and months before it aired. It's certainly the first and so far only Doctor Who story where I saw the sets before I saw the programme. This was at the Longleat Twentieth Anniversary celebration, Classic Who's equivalent of Woodstock. I was there with my whole family, and saw - if I remember rightly - the High Council's meeting room, the UNIT HQ interior, and Borusa's secret control room on display in a marquee. I remember mentally creating my own stories as I walked round the exhibit based on this furniture alone (none were even close to being on the money, by the by).  Next, probably only a few days before transmission, I remember seeing a copy of the tie-in novelisation in WHSmiths (it was mistakenly available in some shops before the TV story had aired, which had never happened before and probably never happened after). I remember lovingly caressing the foil embossed cover, but I did not sneak a peek at the contents. Looking back, I can't believe I was so restrained and am really proud of my young self.

Next comes the bit where I'm less than proud of myself, alas. On the evening of Friday 25th November 1983, the plan was that I would not watch Doctor Who. My sister had a big role in a local am-dram production, and the whole family was going to be in the audience to support her. I was not happy about this, as I did not want to miss the biggest Doctor Who story ever. Friends of the family had promised to tape the show on their new-fangled Betamax top-loader video recorder, and we were visiting them the next day. But I didn't want to wait a whole day to see it, so - amidst shouting and recriminations from all around me - I feigned illness and refused to budge when everyone else left. I watched on my ownsome, sitting through a lot of tedious preamble from Terry Wogan, as Doctor Who was shown as part of Children in Need. Looking back, I feel bad, but at the time I was perfectly happy with my decision - I estimated that The Five Doctors must be considerably better than whatever lame old play my sis was in. I apologise for the crassness of young me. Watching it on Friday did not then stop me from wholeheartedly embracing the viewing on Saturday too. The chance to see something I'd watched the previous night again was something akin to the finest magic. If it hadn't been early 1980s UK, with only one TV per household on average, and certainly only one VCR, I might have asked to watch it all again for a third time; but, the adults wanted to generally be dull and talk or whatever in the living room, so my sister (who was still talking to me, just about) and I retreated to the kid's bedroom - his name was Michael, if memory serves - and talked about our favourite bits. 

I've seen this story a lot in different forms. I watched the repeat the following Summer, which split the story into four twenty-five minute chunks with the worst cliffhangers ever. I bought the VHS when it came out in the early 1990s. Then, in late 1995, a special edition version of The Five Doctors - with a small amount of additional material, improved sound and new effects - was made for release on that magic home format: video tape. By this time, I was very familiar with the technology. It came in a set with preceding story The King's Demons, plus two postcards of each story's cover art (as they had been giving away with all the releases that year), and an album to collect up said postcards, which was smart, and which I still have somewhere. This was special as it is one of one two Doctor Who videos I ever got as a Christmas present. In general, I always snapped them up as they were released, never leaving anyone the opportunity to get them as a gift. I can't remember what happened that year to make me hold off, but it was very nice to unwrap and watch on Christmas day. As I was watching the scene of the Raston warrior robot battling with Cybermen soundtracked in gorgeous beefy stereo, my sister wandered in and listened to the Cyber voices giving it their best take at anguish and devastation, and said "Blobby blobby blobby" then walked away. Fair enough, I suppose. 

Reaction:
Robert Holmes, one of the best regarded of twentieth century Doctor who writers, tried to plot a version of The Five Doctors and couldn't manage it: all the disparate elements, all the many leading men to cater for, all the chops and changes of actors' availability - it was too much. He stepped aside, and Terrance Dicks picked up the baton. They are both fine writers, and there was nobody else around then (and few have come along since) who knew more about writing Doctor Who than the two of them. So, why did Uncle Terrance succeed where Holmes failed? My guess is that Holmes was overthinking it. One thing every fan knows from Holmes's aborted storyline attempt is that at the end the first Doctor (played here by Richard Hurndall, standing in as original actor William Hartnell had passed away) is revealed to be an Auton, explaining why he doesn't look quite right. Dicks just ignores the re-casting and gets on with a straight-ahead action story. Dicks's ability to produce such a simple and effective narrative, given the egregious length of the shopping list of elements he had to include, should not be overlooked: what he overcame had defeated Robert Bloody Holmes, for goodness sake! As such, The Five Doctors is bulletproof when it comes to critiques. It was built to showcase twenty years of Doctor Who, and that it does - anything more than that is a bonus.

So, it's pointless to criticise the structure for being basic and linear: that's a necessity, but also a strength. There's an intro to each Doctor, as they are zapped out of existence by a black triangle. Then there's a bit of each walking around the death zone, before having a couple of exterior set pieces each. Then, they enter the tower, each coincidentally with their own entrance. Then an interior set piece each, then all together for the confrontation with the main villain at the end. Then goodbyes and off they go. There's a subplot about the conspiracy on Gallifrey, but that's as complex as it gets, and even that's only added to give one Doctor something to do, who otherwise would be stuck in the TARDIS (a fate that, as good as he is, Dicks can't help but deliver to two of the many companions involved). Of course it is structured like this: who has time to do fiddly intriguing subplots and reversals when you have to give sufficient action to four leading men (if Tom Baker had agreed to take part, my guess is Richard Hurndall would have stayed in the TARDIS with Susan and Turlough). This is probably why no reunion story of this scale has ever been attempted in Doctor Who since (with the exceptions of two skits of varying degrees of success - more on those below).

What can I say about any of those scenes that hasn't been said a thousand times before (and that goes for positives and negatives)? The use of footage from the unfinished, and at that point widely unseen, Shada to give Tom Baker's Doctor something of a presence in the proceedings is inspired, and the scene of the Doctor and Romana punting on the Cam contains some of Douglas Adams most charming and witty dialogue: "Oh I do love the autumn, all the leaves, colours" is such an unassuming punchline, and delivered with such panache by Lalla Ward, it makes one glad this footage got a BBC1 airing. Until the Special edition in 1995 "fixed" things, it had never occurred to me as odd that the picture used to represent the two Time Lords stuck in the vortex didn't match what they'd been wearing in the punt. It also never bothered me that the Doctor is returned to his timestream stuck halfway under a wire fence - it just seemed like a bit of a laugh. 
  
The scenes of the Raston warrior robot - the one original element included here - slaughtering a platoon of Cybermen is magnificent. One of the Cybers vomits - it's amazing! It's very satisfying for the obsessive statto nerds like me that Jon Pertwee finally got to encounter the Cybermen (which he never did during his original tenure). Troughton gets all the best lines, which is the sensible choice as he is the best at delivering them; partnering him with Nicholas Courtney as the Brigadier is successful too - they make a great double act. Hurndall is enjoying getting to be a hero (just for one day), and holds his own. The scene with him, Susan and the Dalek is nice, and it's great to see the shell exploded and the grisly, squiddly Kaled mutant inside for the first time in the series (that was an effect that they demonstrated at the Longleat celebration too, now I think of it).There's a cameo from K9, and another from Jamie and Zoe, and Liz Shaw screaming "Stop Hiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiim!" What more could you want?

One bit that most fascinates me is the chequered floor sequence featuring the Master, Cybermen, and the first Doctor and Tegan (Dicks's drafts are showing here - why on Earth would those two be paired unless it was a remnant of a version where Tom Baker was the one investigating the conspiracy on Gallifrey, and Davison was allowed to adventure in the zone with his longest-running companion?!). The director Peter Moffat was well known for bringing productions in on budget in as unfussy a manner as possible, to the point where his work can look terribly pedestrian. That isn't so much of a problem here, likely helped by a more generous budget than usual, and a lot of his work looks excellent - particularly the location footage in the Welsh hills, and the beautifully lit sequence with Troughton attacked in a cave by a Yeti. He couldn't make much visual excitement out of a tiled floor, though, but who could? It's a floor. What's annoying though is that Moffat doesn't seem to have thought it necessary to help the actors to work out what is the logic of this floor trigger puzzle, and move accordingly to sell it to the watching audience.

Anthony Ainley's Master walks inconsistently over it multiple times, with differing levels of care about exactly where he's treading.  On at least one occasion, his foot falls at a point where four different squares intersect. They paper over this by adding a line on how the safe path changes every time, but it's hardly satisfactory. Every time I've watched this - and that is more times than is healthy, believe me - I've scoured for any discernible rules to how the chessboard of death operates, and there are none. The scene still, though, intrigues me more and more - it just gives and won't stop giving. The Master tells the Doctor it's as "easy as pi" and somehow the Doctor hears this homophonic clue, even though it's far from obvious. Tegan is chided about her grasp of mathematics and says, haltingly "the ratio of the circumference of a circle to its diameter is represented by the Greek letter pi, right?" which is a 1980s companion language translation of the human English which would run something like "pi is that thing to do with circles, right?". But then, Tegan, on being presented with a keypad to open a door earlier, exclaims with astonished joy "An entry coder!" which is not an actual phrase that's ever been used by anyone ever. I was an entry-level coder once upon a long time ago in my day job, but it's not the same thing. Why aren't 1980s companions allowed to speak human? I suspect script editor Eric Saward of being behind this guff, as Terrance Dicks can usually craft rounded human characters who speak naturally.

Anyway, back to the killer floor covering, the laser lino: the Doctor muses on the application of pi to work out the safe route, pauses for a moment, then walks across successfully. But how? What has pi got to do with it? Is it each digit of pi in turn refers to the safe column to walk down? Or the unsafe one? How can the Doctor possibly work out the safe route just from that? Also, how did the Master know in the first place? He gets to that part of the tower after the Doctor and Tegan, and is never seen experimenting. How did he work it out? Also, once the Master has tricked the Cybermen into getting themselves killed crossing the floor, why can't the Doctor and Tegan just step on them to get to the other side? As I said, I may have watched this story more times than is healthy...

Connectivity: 
It's not very hard to link The Five Doctors to any other story as it contains such a broad coverage of elements from throughout Doctor Who history. Like The Android Invasion, it features appearances by Tom Baker as the Doctor and Elizabeth Sladen as Sarah Jane Smith, members of UNIT, blank faced robotic killers with their armaments built in, and creatures created by Terry Nation. In both stories, Sarah Jane is rescued from a pathetically un-steep cliff edge.

Deeper Thoughts:
First as tragedy, second as farce, third as farce again (but better). In the 30+ years since The Five Doctors, the series proper has never again tried to bring together such a crazy big set of Doctors and companions as the 20th anniversary story managed. It's done two Doctors working together with returning companions (The Two Doctors) and without (Twice Upon a Time), and two Doctors plus a new Doctor, and a brief cameo scene for all the Doctors using clips (The Day of the Doctor). It's brought back loads of old enemies but no old Doctors a few times (The Pandorica Opens, The Time of the Doctor), and that's about it. Someone must have worked out that it's damn near impossible to pull off a passable story again unless one keeps things more restricted, even if you have the talent of Terrance Dicks to write it. Lightning cannot strike twice. If one wants evidence of this, one only has to look at the time they did try such a feat again outside of the series proper: Dimensions in Time.

For the 30th anniversary in 1993, Doctor Who had been off air for a while, but was doing healthy business on sell-through VHS. There had been an idea to create a one-off feature length story specifically to be sold on tape, called The Dark Dimension. They would have worked out the 'too many Doctors for one plot' problem by giving the lion's share of the action to Tom Baker, and had the others pop-up for cameos here and there. The other Doctors, perhaps understandably, did not like this idea, and anyway the whole thing fell through. A consolation prize was that a short skit was going to be shot and shown - like The Five Doctors - as part of Children in Need. It was only about 15 minutes long, and split into two episodes, with a phone vote in between (nothing says early to mid 1990s like a pointless phone vote) to decide whether Mandy or Big Ron would appear in part 2. For you see, Dimensions in Time was a Doctor Who / Eastenders cross-over. Oh yes! It was rubbish of course, and watching it in my third year at university, old enough to know better, I clenched in embarrassment at Noel Edmonds taking the piss when introducing it.

The piece was shot in a 3D format that required objects to be placed unnecessarily in the foreground, and for the camera to keep circling all the time. As such, it is not recommended if you have a hangover. Tom Baker has his hair cut disappointingly short, and doesn't interact with anyone else, just appearing on his own in a prologue. Louise Jameson as Leela is dressed as Pocahontas for some reason, many companions don't look anything like they did when they were first in the show. There are no Daleks, so presumably Terry Nation had got in a strop and taken his ball away. Most of the interaction with the Eastenders characters is woeful. Frank and the Mitchell brothers handle it okay. And there's a great moment when Mike Yates arrives in Bessie, and he and the Pertwee Doctor drive off, meeting the Brigadier who arrives by helicopter. Then Pertwee turns into Colin Baker (did I mention that the Doctor and companions turn into one another rather than all appearing together? Oh yes!). This gives good fan service, just as putting Jon Pertwee with Cybermen in The Five Doctors did, as Colin and the Brig never got a story together on TV during his tenure. Kate o' Mara reprising her role as the Rani is great despite her over-ripe dialogue, and a young Sam West gets to act as her companion, and he comes out the other side with his dignity more or less intact. All the many villains are played by fans wearing old costumes, but en masse they acquire a sort of tatty majesty. 

The one thing that's missing is a joke, any joke. It is curiously humour-free for a skit, but this is not unusual in my experience of Children in Need or Comic Relief segments such as this. For a funny Doctor Who short one would have had to wait another 20 years for the marvellous Five-ish Doctors Reboot that was shown on the night of Doctor Who's 50th anniversary, which - in its own way - managed to reunite multiple Doctors and still have a sensible plot through-line. Anyway, Dimensions in Time was the only scrap of new Doctor Who shown on BBC1 between the end of Sylvester McCoy's run in 1989 and Paul McGann's one night stand in 1996, so it has a misplaced home in the affections of fans of a certain age (mine!). Because of the conditions of its making, with the performers working for charity, it can never be released on any home format or shown on TV again, but it can be found on the internet, if you've never seen it. Brace yourself! 

In Summary:
Five times the fun, just don't overthink it.

Sunday, 24 November 2019

Terminus

Chapter The 139th, concerns Terminus, definition - noun: the end of the line.

Plot:
The Doctor has welcomed Turlough aboard the TARDIS, not knowing that this new young companion is a somewhat unwilling agent of the Black Guardian tasked with assassinating the Time Lord. Only Tegan suspects Turlough, but no one listens to her as she's always moaning about something. Anyway, Turlough's attempts at time machine sabotage cause the TARDIS to lock on to a nearby craft, which is decorated with pictures of skulls everywhere, so obviously must be a safe haven. Nyssa's room is nearest to the ensuing cosmic disturbance, so she escapes into the craft and the others follow her, getting split up as is the fashion. The Doctor and Nyssa meet up with a couple of space pirates, a raiding party whose (space)ship-mates have abandoned them, as it turns out they've raided a plague (space)ship - ferrying victims of space leprosy to a space station called Terminus. In Space.

Nyssa has caught the disease (somehow), and gets taken off by guards called the Vanir. The others follow. Once there, they aren't really in any jeopardy, except for some minor league bullying from the Vanir, as everyone - even a giant glowing red-eyed man-dog called the Garm - actually does want to help cure the people that arrive there. It also turns out that Terminus is at the exact centre of the universe (!) and its engines firing were responsible for the big bang because of some timey-warping (!!). The Black Guardian tricks Turlough into another act of sabotage which starts the Terminus engines again, threatening to destroy the universe, and everything comes to a crescendo with the giant dog-man pushing a lever back to its off position (!!!). Tegan and Turlough spend 90% of the story crawling around in air ducts, by the way, with the former only emerging at the end to be told by Nyssa that she's leaving the TARDIS, and is sticking around to help run Terminus. Tegan gives her a big hug, thereby offering her arms to an ex-leper. Arms to an ex-leper? No? No... I'll see myself out.

Context:
When Terminus came up next on the randomiser, I groaned inwardly. It's one of those stories I never find too appealing for a rewatch. A tired and tatty reputation proceeds it, but being stuck in the middle of a loose trilogy of stories, and writing out a companion, it can't be skipped; so, it tends to be watched only out of a stubborn and gruelling sense of duty. Watched alone without the bookends of the far more fun stories either side (Mawdryn Undead before, and Enlightenment after) is particularly hard. Poor Terminus. If Nyssa didn't leave in this story, I don't know if anyone would ever watch it all, as it's got naff all to do with the 'Black Guardian trilogy' really, as a friend of mine once observed (see below). My unfavourable feeling going in may have been subconsciously broadcast to my viewing mates, as all the children (boys of 13 and 10, girl of 7) bailed after episode 1, never to return. I watched the remainder of the story from the DVD, an episode a night, on my own. It does get a bit better as it goes along. (I watched without the enhanced CGI, by the way, because - to be honest - I'd completely forgotten until after I'd seen the episodes and was exploring the disc that there were any replacement CGI effects for Terminus).

First time round:
I did catch this on its BBC1 broadcast in February 1983, but don't remember anything significant about that viewing. I wasn't madly in love with Nyssa like some of my peers at that time, so neither her leaving, nor the sight of her in a camisole and petticoat, meant much to me. I remember more about the VHS release, which came out approximately ten years later. This was during my second year at university in Durham, when I'd gravitated towards a group of like-minded (or at least tolerant and slightly nostalgic) individuals who would watch Doctor Who with me. I bought the tape in Volume One in Worthing, my usual supplier of the time, and watched it at home before term started. Then, a month or so later, as I remember it, a few of us visited a group of friends' student digs in Neville's Cross on a Sunday, and watched my tapes of the whole of the Black Guardian trilogy back to back. God, we knew how to live back then. David, long-term fan friend mentioned many times before on this blog, was there, as was Kev B, another friend from his year group. They both must have been visiting for the weekend as they had left Durham the previous year. l remember having a discussion on the day with David about whether it was still worth watching a terrestrial repeat of Doctor Who if you already have it on video  - they were showing old Whos on BBC2 on Friday evenings, but it was something like Genesis of the Daleks or Caves of Androzani on at the time, which I had on tape, so I didn't bother watching; David, on the other hand, thought that any Doctor Who being shown 'live', as it were, was exciting and I should support it. Three-quarters of the way through watching Terminus, Kev B spluttered in frustration "This has got nothing to do with all the Black Guardian stuff". And he was right.

Reaction:
The author of Terminus, Steven Gallagher, is a pretty good writer, and one of only a handful of classic series Doctor Who writers who made a big name for themselves with significant work away from the show (novels and TV series, in his case). His previous script, Warrior's Gate, certainly had some problems during its production, but on the page it sings. So, why's Terminus such a mess? It too had a cursed production, where it seemed everything that could possibly go wrong did, but there's major issues with the script too. No production, however swish, could save it. Just to take one example, consider the mysterious company Terminus Inc. that runs this healthcare institution. As we find out later, the cure they offer does work, although it's hit and miss. So, why does nobody ever return? Why do people keep paying them, if their reputation is so bad (as pretty much every character confirms - it's not just the pirate Olvir's bias). Olvir says that the company continues operating, and nobody complains, because having a relative with the disease is too shameful for anyone to make a fuss. Do we buy that? If someone with enough money or clout paid for someone with the disease to be cured, and they disappeared without a trace, surely they would investigate? How likely is it that only un-rich or un-influential people are affected by Lazar disease?

Well, maybe it is possible, as Lazar disease doesn't seem to be one of those dull diseases that follows logic or anything; instead it claims only the person in the cast whose contract was coming to an end, leaving lots of other people unaffected who had as much or more contact with infected people or atmosphere. It also strikes insanely rapidly, which makes one wonder how anyone could survive an intergalactic trip once they came down with it. Let it also not be forgot that one of the symptoms is to take one's clothes off, wander around in one's undies for a bit, then don some medieval peasant rags. It is indubitably an unusual and interesting disease.

The Garm's motivations at least make sense, but he is woefully badly realised. This era (and pretty much all of classic Doctor Who, to be honest) has its fair share of monster creation being fumbled on the journey from script to screen, but they're not always so damaging to the intent of the story. The Garm as he finally appeared looks like a cuddly big teddy bear. He looks friendly, which of course - he is! He's supposed to look terrifying, so that when we find out later that he's friendly, it's a surprise twist. A key part of the story is fatally undermined, plus, you know, the Garm looks embarrassing throughout too - everyone's a loser. Gallagher's gone on record saying that the original script had the Garm remain unseen, just a pair of glowing eyes in the darkness; that would definitely have worked better, but would have been hard to realise in the studio, and eventually the whole costume would have had to be revealed as the Garm has to help save the day at the end.

Without the terrifying version of the Garm as originally intended, Terminus doesn't even have a pretend antagonist. That's not necessarily a fault, though; I think it's one of the story's few strengths is that Nyssa stirs up a quiet and small revolution amongst characters that aren't big and bad and evil, but just normal - if slightly desperate - people; it suits her character, and it's refreshing that the stakes don't always have to be high. Other positives: Bor is a good character, and nicely played by Peter Benson. And Liza Goddard trying her hardest to make her hard-bitten space pirate character believable, despite everything around her, from her costume and make-up outwards, working against that, is a triumph of determination.

Connectivity: 
Not very much links the black-and-white historical The Reign of Terror to the 1980s space adventure that is Terminus. All I can think of is that their respective first episodes both have a lot of wandering around exploring, with only a couple of guest characters appearing, then the rest of the cast - and the plot - turns up from episode two onwards.

Deeper Thoughts:
Vanessa Feltz's Grandmother. There's clearly much that is risible in Terminus, but a moment that  - though it is indeed silly - had never much registered previously, was part of an early scene. Peter Davison rushes into a room to see the door on the far side rapidly closing, so throws a chair with almost supernatural accuracy into the gap, stopping the door from slamming shut altogether. British TV whimsy-merchant Harry Hill and his writing team must have been tickled by this when researching material for an appearance of Peter Davison on Hill's Alien Fun Capsule programme last year. The result was a game / sketch called Chair Jam in which Peter and the other guests compete to best recreate this historic television event. The clip is online here and it's a lot of fun. If you haven't seen it, a note of caution before you click on that link: you won't be able to see that moment of Terminus the same way ever again. Now, I know that often gets said, but this time I think it's true: every time I watch Terminus from now on (which probably won't be that often, but you never know) the chair moment is going to stick out, and I'm going to think of Harry Hill.

This is a phenomenon of which I'm very familiar: there are lots of moments or lines of dialogue in films or TV shows that have become stuck in my mind by association with something else. Normally, it's experienced the other way round, though; rather than be reminded of something when watching a show, I'm reminded of the show when doing something else. This normally then elicits a quote in recognition, at least in our house. I don't know if 'normal' people do this. A couple of examples: whenever the Better Half or I are involved in any risky or thankless endeavour, one will say to the other "It won't work, will it, Ted?" and the other will reply "No, but we have to try" - this is based on the exchange between Ted and Dougal in the series two Father Ted episode Tentacles of Doom.  When there's no food in the house, and we need to do a big supermarket run, it is consistently known as a 'lentils and wallpaper' shop, after the shopping list Neil starts to write when they need "everything" in The Young Ones episode Flood. There's loads of others too - the semiotic thickness of our day-to-day dialogue is such that, were we not allowed our meta-textual references, it would probably get a lot quieter in our house.

There are obviously lots of Doctor Who instances too, some of which I've mentioned in the blog before. Whenever someone says anything patently obvious in our house, they receive an impression of Mr. Sneed in The Unquiet Dead: "The whole blummin' world can see that!". At least once a day throughout our summer holiday this year, someone sitting at the poolside but not getting in would be told by someone in the pool "You shouldah come intah the wartah wiv us, then we'dah bin tuggevah", parroting what is, I think we can all agree, the finest line of dialogue in The Curse of Fenric. Whenever, there's a discussion about 'fire' or 'leaders' it won't be long before "There were leaders before there was fire; fire will kill us all in the end" makes its entrance (Old Mother's dialogue from An Unearthly Child, done in an exaggerated impression of Eileen Way's delivery).

I'm going out on a limb here a bit, but I think that Doctor Who fans understand this behaviour; a particular Doctor Who fan - Russell T Davies - wrote about it. In an exchange between Lance and Henry in episode six of his 2015 series Cucumber, Lance tells how he once read an article by Vanessa Feltz about her grandmother doing the washing-up, always with the water too hot to the touch. This is also how Lance likes to do the washing up, so: "Every time I wash up, I think of Vanessa Feltz's grandmother. Isn't that ridiculous? Every single day of my life, just for a second, I think of Vanessa Feltz's grandmother. Cos she's in there, she's stuck - she's this tiny little fact that won't go away". Like all good bits of dramatic observation, this made me feel understood, and part of something wider. Since then, all our little family catchphrases and the regular events that invoke them have become known as Vanessa Feltz's Grandmother moments. The only drawback with this is the cognitive pile up: when it's cold and someone wants the fire put on I am reminded of Old Mother's portentous pronouncements in An Unearthly Child which reminds me of Lance and Henry in Cucumber which reminds me of Vanessa Feltz's grandmother. It's a wonder I get anything done!

In Summary:
If Terminus didn't exist, there would be no Chair Jam, and Chair Jam's quite funny; so, that's in its favour.